Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

More Than Money: Rentier Politics in Qatar (Pre-Recorded)

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

How does Qatar, one of the richest and smallest rentier regimes in the world, challenge conventional theoretical explanations about how domestic politics works in the modern rentier state? Rentier states such as Qatar accrue their wealth from external sources, like the sale of oil and gas. This financial self-sufficiency frees the state from having to rely on domestic taxation for its wealth. For decades, rentier states have been analyzed through the lens of rentier state theory (RST), which posits that this financial self-sufficiency gives the state much more political power over society than is normally seen in non-rentier states. This imbalance of power, so the theory goes, enables the rentier state to pursue domestic policies without the kinds of state-society interactions that typically take place in non-rentier states, where taxation is linked to the expectation that citizens will receive political representation. Rather, the rentier state maintains its political power over society by means of the rentier bargain: The state channels wealth to individuals and groups, creating economic satisfaction that, in turn, secures acceptance of its legitimacy and authority. This top-down control of wealth, RST claims, is all that is required to secure popular support for the state’s domestic policy agenda. In short, the conventional answer to the question of how domestic politics works in a rentier state is: The citizens bargain away their political voice and influence in exchange for state-distributed wealth.

Rentier state theory is used regularly in policy pieces, media reports, and scholarly analyses to explain and predict the domestic politics of this type of nation. But more recent studies of domestic rentier politics have challenged RST’s singular focus on the rentier bargain (such as Hertog [2010] and Krane [2019] in Saudi Arabia, Herb [2014] in Kuwait, Gengler [2015] in Bahrain, Jones [2017] in the UAE). In line with these analyses, this paper uses the case study of Qatar to contend that this quintessential rentier state’s domestic politics cannot be explained by RST’s focus on material transactions alone.

A cursory glance would indicate that Qatar validates, rather than contests, RST’s assertion that wealth distribution forms the backbone of domestic rentier politics. The Qatari state distributes its wealth from rents both directly and indirectly to its citizens, and domestic politics do currently function well in Qatar. But analysis of original, nationally representative survey data reveals that Qatari citizens are not actually as economically satisfied with these material distributions as RST predicts. This dissatisfaction stems from deep tensions between different societal groups in Qatar that the top-down distribution of wealth exacerbates, rather than smooths over. This unexpected economic dissatisfaction, and its consequences, suggest that the well-functioning domestic politics of Qatar cannot be explained by a focus on material transactions alone. What else, then, is needed to make domestic politics work in Qatar?

Classic RST dismisses it as unnecessary and even unwise for a rentier government to invest in top-down narratives of identity and nationalism, because the theory predicts that popular acceptance of state legitimacy is already secure. Yet one sees Qatar expending huge resources on nation-building narratives that target citizens and expatriate residents alike, as it seeks to cultivate popular support for its domestic policy agenda. And those efforts are by no means met with unquestioning buy-in. Even with a wave of nationalist fervor spurred by the regional crisis begun in June 2017, when neighboring countries Bahrain, Saudi Arabia, and the UAE closed their borders to Qatar and cut diplomatic and economic ties, Qatari citizens and residents still react to the state’s nationalistic narratives sometimes with approval and other times with dissent. There is no more striking example of this than the new National Museum of Qatar, where state-promoted definitions of heritage, tribalism, and belonging contrast with deep societal concerns. Utilizing a mix of survey data, fieldwork, and ethnographic interviews, the paper’s in-depth analysis of the museum’s narratives illuminates the ongoing contestations over a singular national identity in Qatar and shows how society, indeed, actively engages in nation-building alongside the state.

In sum, this paper builds on the unexpected economic dissatisfaction among citizens to highlight the importance of national identity—and the deep contestations between the state and multiple societal groups over the definition of this identity. The findings presented suggest that making domestic politics work in a rentier state may require a give-and-take between state and society that far transcends the rentier bargain, expanding both our empirical knowledge of an important global player and our theoretical understanding of domestic politics in modern rentier nations.

Author