Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In 2019, Governor Jay Inslee (D-WA) launched his presidential campaign with a video declaring, “I am the only candidate who will make defeating climate change our nation’s number one priority.” President Donald Trump’s environmental protection rollbacks, withdrawal from the Paris Climate Agreement, and rhetoric stood in stark contrast to his Democratic counterparts, going so far as to call climate change a “hoax” during the 2016 elections (BBC, 2018). How candidates talk about an issue like climate change, either by legitimizing it by acknowledging its wide-ranging impact and making it the heart of their campaign or delegitimizing it by calling it a hoax, can affect how voters prioritize the issue (Hayes, 2008), as well as affect voters’ knowledge about the issue and how they vote (Jamieson et al., 2000).
The current study examines how 2020 presidential candidates framed climate change during the primary season across two important dimensions. First, this study tracks candidates’ climate change framing on Twitter and assesses which messages received more retweets and favorites. Frames are typically more powerful and accessible when they are repeated (Chong & Druckman, 2007; Entman, 2003). Twitter provides users an easy way to repeat a candidate’s frame via retweets. Therefore analyzing which frames receive the most retweets indicates to some extent which frames are more powerful and accessible, and thus potentially more top of mind for Twitter users. Frames can also be more powerful when they have resonance. Snow and Benford (1988) argue a frame’s “appeal and mobilizing potency are affected by…the extent to which the framing effort is relevant to or resonates within the life world of potential participants” (p. 205). Scholarship shows that Twitter features such as retweets and favorites indicate favorable evaluations (boyd et al., 2010; Meier et al., 2014; Metaxas & TwitterTrails Research Team, 2017), thus suggesting resonance, and providing a glimpse into what messages were connecting with the public.
Second, candidate communication about climate change is varied because the issue itself is complex and intertwined with an array of other issues, and because candidates’ ideologies, identities, and targeted voters shape their messages. For example, Democratic elites and voters prioritize climate change more than Republicans and are more supportive of mitigation efforts (see Nisbet, 2009; Tyson & Kennedy, 2020). Further, the public perceives Democrats, women, and people of color as more effective at handling climate change and environmental justice issues (Brown & Gershon, 2016; Pew, 2015; 2018). Because it can behoove candidates to prioritize issues in which they are perceived as capable (Benoit, 2007), it is possible candidates of varying party, gender, and racial identities may elevate and frame climate change differently. This study examines candidates’ framing differences based on their partisanship, gender, and race/ethnicity.
This study is guided by several research questions: RQ1: How do candidates frame climate change? RQ2: Which climate change frames receive the most retweets and favorites? RQ3: Comparatively, which climate change frames are used by and receive the most retweets and favorites for Republican and Democratic candidates? RQ4: Comparatively, which climate change frames are used by and receive the most retweets and favorites for Democratic women and men, as well as Republican men? RQ5: Comparatively, which climate change frames are used by and receive the most retweets and favorites for candidates at the intersection of party, gender, and race?
I will implement a quantitative content analysis of 23 Republican and Democratic presidential candidates from the 2020 primary season. The timeframe stretches from November 2019 to April 2020, when Bernie Sanders dropped out, leaving Joe Biden and Donald Trump as the presumptive nominees. I will use a preset codebook, based on previous scholarship, to analyze the candidates’ campaign tweets during this timeframe. By systematically analyzing candidates’ frames, this study can track how they contributed to public discourse and public knowledge about climate change and its effects. Further, by assessing which frames received the most engagement, this study can provide practical guidance to campaigns about which frames resonate with the tweeting public across a candidate’s party, gender, and race.