Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Can Deliberation Have Lasting Effects?

Tue, September 28, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Does Deliberation produce any lasting effects? “America in One Room” was a national field experiment in which more than 500 registered voters were brought together from all over the country to deliberate in depth over a long weekend on five major issues facing the country. A pre-post control group was also asked the same questions. The deliberators showed large changes of opinion compared to the control group questioned over the same period. But the participants then returned to their home environments in the middle of a highly partisan and hotly contested presidential campaign. The deliberators and the control group were reinterviewed twice: first, after ten months just before the national party conventions and second, after a year just before the 2020 presidential election. Many of the effects on policy attitudes dissipated but there were very large differences in voting intention among the deliberators compared to the control group. This paper attempts to account for these effects. If deliberation has lasting effects, then it provides a rationale for attempts to scale the deliberative process to much larger numbers. The paper considers methods for doing so in the context of the broader debate about mini-publics, isolated spheres of deliberation situated within a largely non-deliberative society.

Authors