Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Deliberative Polling with Automated Moderation: A First Application in Japan

Tue, September 28, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

For the first time, the Stanford Online Deliberation Platform, which features an automated moderator, was used for a Tokyo-city wide deliberation on solar energy policy in Spring 2020. The platform , based on the Deliberative Polling method, uses an automated moderator, which enables deliberative events to efficiently organize numerous small group deliberations without the logistics or cost of human moderators. The automated moderator maintains civility in the discussion, encourages equitable participation by all participants, asks participants to consider arguments from both sides of all proposals, and provides a structured collaboration phase for participants to deliberate and seek agreement on key questions for competing experts. In between their small group discussions, there were plenary sessions where all participants gathered with experts to answer the questions developed in their small groups. In the Tokyo-wide deliberation, more than 200 participants took more in a day-long deliberation. Participants' experienced significant opinion changes and evaluated the event and platform very favorably. In this paper, the authors compare the results of this online deliberation with results from comparable Japanese in-person deliberations, in order to explore whether the online deliberations had similar results and participant experience.

Authors