Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Co-founder (along with Dorothy Day) of the American Catholic Worker Movement, Peter Maurin, once said of his politics that all he wanted was “a world in which it was easier for men to be good.” Like much within the Catholic tradition this deceptively simple construction proves to be immeasurably dense and notoriously difficult to unpack, explicate, and act upon if taken to heart. Among the many questions raised by Maurin’s call are complicated questions like what does it mean to be good? What would make it easier to be such a person once we have defined it? What are the obstacles that exist to achieving such a state of being and where did they come from and how might they be effectively removed or confronted? Each layer, as it is peeled back, revealing more questions in need of answers and more terms in need of definitions until suddenly it dawns on the investigator that what will be required to produce such a world is not a mere technical answer, but rather a complete worldview that confronts issues ranging from theology and metaphysics to epistemology and philosophy to anthropology and culture to political theory and the mechanics of public policy and politics itself. It is far less cumbersome to simply ask people what they desire and then work to determine whether you are willing to give it to them or not and, if so, how to do it. Maurin’s purported quest is grounded in what can be called a “relational” view of the world whereas that latter approach is what we now call “transactional.”
In this paper, I will argue that Catholic politics are, at their core, always relational when properly ordered. When the politics of Catholics become merely transactional they are, by the standards of the faith, disordered. While Catholics as citizens are not immune to the simple seductions and relatively uncomplicated bargains that comprise a transactional approach to the political order, when they partake of it intentionally and without regard to the relational questions they do so in manner inconsistent with both the teachings of their Church and the “political theology” that those teachings assert and authorize in the name of the faith. The body of thought that comprises the “political” teaching of the Church in the modern world is collectively called Catholic Social Teaching (CST). Two political theorists pithily summed up the CST in the following way:
1. All people matter all of the time.
2. It is not just about me and my stuff.
Both assertions deny a firm purchase to any simple mode of transactional politics. And, like Maurin’s construction above, both are fraught with complexity when taken seriously. It is the larger argument of this paper that with the election of Joe Biden to the Presidency of the United States, that we will have in that office for the first time a Catholic who is both formed in and by that tradition and who is guided by it and embraces its tenets in a manner that is both intentional and faith filled. Beyond that claim, the paper will also argue that Biden’s form of Catholicism which he describes as being as much “cultural” as “theological” is, at its core, of a piece with the kind of “personalism” that ground Maurin and Day’s thinking to a point and is best articulated by the French theorist, Emmanual Mounier in his 1950 treatise Personalism. If I am correct, this will have implications for his political prospects and agenda that will at times confound members of his own party as well as the parties of his rivals and render him what Glen Tinder once called an “unreliable ally” of both the right and the left.
In an essay penned in October of 2020, for the Christian Post, titled: “The greatest commandment has guided my politics,” Biden explains that “loving God and loving others” are the abiding principles at the very foundation of his faith.
He goes on to link this ideal to the American founding principles and claims that “As president, these are the principles that will shape all that I do, and my faith will continue to serve as my anchor, as it has shaped my entire life.” In a tight six page essay, Biden produces what in less chaotic times might have been seen as among the most radical challenges to the neo-liberal consensus and instrumental approach to politics in the U.S. by any candidate for high office in the history of the nation.
This is not simply playing to the audience. It is, I will contend, at the heart of Biden’s political philosophy and approach to government. The radical love of neighbor as a unique and sacred person—a “someone” rather than a “something” – is at the root of who he is and what will guide him for better or worse in the four years to come. His attempt to Americanize what is actually quite foreign to the American mind will be both profound and potentially disconcerting and discomforting for many. In other words, it may well be prophetic with all the risks such a voice often has entailed in the earthly kingdom.