Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Charles Taylor on the Moral Imaginary of the Biden Presidency

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

How does a Catholic president navigate the deep divisions between late modern politics and Catholicism? In this paper I analyze the political possibilities for Biden’s political Catholicism in terms of the work of Charles Taylor.

Charles Taylor is one of the greatest social theorists of recent decades, and his work is profoundly shaped by his Catholic faith. He is thus a unique guide for the public roles of Catholicism and religion generally in modernity. Taylor not only articulates key aspects of the modern condition in which any politician today must govern, but he offers resources for engaging modernity that any leader will have to grapple with, and particularly a Catholic like Biden.

Specifically, I offer a three-part argument. First, I argue that Taylor’s key concepts (a) social imaginary and his unique understanding of (b) secularism can articulate the conditions of pluralism in which Biden finds himself. Second, the articulation of those conditions in turn helps to situate and contextualize the political and moral resources of Biden’s Catholicism, which Taylor himself can also offer critical vistas toward in his account of the roles and functions of religion in modernity. Third, I showcase the possibilities thus disclosed with reference to refugee policy.

I first explain how Taylor’s descriptive account of modernity draws out the horizon of the Biden administration. The first aspect is the social imaginary, what Taylor calls the modern moral order (MMO). As Taylor notes in his 2002 article “Modern Social Imaginaries,” a social imaginary is the horizon in which people live: “the ways in which people imagine their social existence, how they fit together with others, how things go on between them and their fellows, the expectations that are normally met, and the deeper normative notions and images that underlie these expectations.”

The second aspect is Taylor’ innovative conceptualization of secularism. Secularism for Taylor in his 2007 book A Secular Age indicates not merely decline in religious belief or institutional spaces set apart from religion, but shifts in the condition of belief itself, such that unbelief and belief are equally available options. In a society that is secular in this sense, no form of belief can make a claim to institutional and normative privilege, including Biden’s own Catholicism.

These concepts, secularism and the modern social imaginary, together reveal the contingency of the Western political, social and economic order, the term “order” being used loosely. Taylor shows that this matrix is not simply the logical result of modernization, nor formed naturally through a “subtraction” story of shedding superstition and religion in the face of Enlightenment. Western modernity has evolved from a concatenation of causes and continues to develop and change. And although it has never developed in isolation from the rest of the world, in late modernity the challenges of pluralism within the West as well as vis-a-vis the Global South are particularly clear. The ways in which the West understands itself with respect to what Taylor sees as its pillars - the market economy, the public sphere, and the self-governing people - are as fragile as ever.

I second show how laying out these concepts helps to frame important questions for Biden. How can Biden positively impact the modern social imaginary, and what possibilities does it offer for policies that promote fundamental common goods in equitable and inclusive ways? Perhaps most importantly, how can Biden proceed with a sense of the pluralism and contingency of the Western political, social and economic conditions?

Here we cannot ignore Taylor’s rich account of Catholicism. Taylor frequently adverts to the character of pre-modern social imaginaries, much of which continue to inform Catholic identity, belief and practice. Most importantly, Catholicism offers a different notion of subjectivity, resisting the disintegration of the person between market economy, public square and private life. Further, one of Taylor’s most incisive discussions of pre-modern religion concerns the tension between theory and practice. Granting the composition of the Democratic party, and indeed the United States, as a diverse coalition of stakeholders, the relation between the practical and the ideal will be crucial to the Biden administration: harmonizing disparate theoretical visions within the bounds of the possible.

I conclude with a case study on refugee policy. Welcoming displaced persons to the US requires articulating the political, social and economic contours in which those persons are being welcomed, meaning that fruitful refugee policy must be sensitive to the Western social imaginary as instantiated in the US, including pervasive resistance to and suspicion of the other, e.g., displaced persons. I thus hope to show how Biden’s Catholicism offers tools to support one of the US’ oldest political traditions: welcoming the stranger.

Author