Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Intergroup Conflict Cross-Culturally Heightens Preferences for Dominant Leaders

Fri, October 1, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Research shows that voters and followers exhibit heightened preferences for dominant or ‘strong leaders’ in situations of intergroup conflict such as terrorist attacks, war or other kinds of threatening interstate behavior (e.g. Merolla & Zechmeister, 2009; Little et al., 2007; Spisak et al., 2012; Laustsen & Petersen, 2017, 2020). Importantly, the relationship between intergroup conflict and follower preferences for dominant leadership holds for female as well as male leaders (Ferguson et al., 2019) and similar results emerge regardless of whether dominance impressions stem from textual descriptions of leaders’ personalities (Laustsen & Petersen, 2020) or from visual (Spisak et al., 2012) or vocal appearances (Tigue et al., 2012).
Intergroup conflict constitutes an evolutionarily recurrent phenomenon (Wrangham & Peterson, 1997; Bowles 2009; Glowacki et al. 2020), and, in essence, it constitutes an arms race between rival groups in being better coordinated (Fessler & Holbrook, 2014). Theoretical work suggests that handing decision making authority and leadership to a dominant individual who is willing to enforce the needed coordination among fellow group members constitutes one way to successfully navigate intergroup conflicts (von Rueden et al., 2014; Petersen & Laustsen, 2020). Accordingly, it is theorized that humans possess an evolved and universal psychological system of adaptive followership, which flexibly up- or downregulates preferences for leader dominance as a function of the intensity of intergroup conflict (Laustsen & Petersen, 2017; von Rueden & van Vugt, 2015). Recent developments in the behavioral and psychological sciences underline the importance of testing claims of universality outside the context of Western, Educated, Industrialized, Rich, and Democratic (i.e. WEIRD) countries (Henrich et al., 2010; Barrett, 2020). However, existing research on the connection between intergroup conflict and follower preferences for leader dominance is based exclusively on studies conducted in the US or Western Europe. In other words, the central claim that the adaptive followership psychology constitutes a human universal remains untested.
Here we report the results from a large-scale, cross-cultural data collection that seeks to test the universality of theorized followership psychology. Specifically, we tested if subjects across the Globe—spanning 25 countries from six continents such as Colombia, Kenya, Pakistan, Hungary and China—hold stronger preferences for dominant leaders in times of intergroup conflict compared to a neutral control condition. Likewise, we test if subjects downregulate their preferences for leader dominance in a no-conflict condition (again compared to the neutral control condition). Finally, we explore how country-level indicators of history of interstate encounters relate to preferences for leader dominance in the neutral control condition.
Our research design combines existing state-of-the-art experimental protocols with strong comparative elements. First, we evoke dominant trait impressions from facial morphs of culturally matched target leader faces (i.e. using African faces in Kenya and Nigeria; Caucasian faces in Denmark and the Netherlands etc.). Second, we randomly assign subjects to conditions of intergroup conflict. Third, we conduct identical studies in countries varying on a range of cultural, institutional and historical features permitting a strong test of the universality and generalizability of the relationship between intergroup conflict and preferences for dominant leadership.
Results (total N=5,064, averaging more than 200 subjects per sampled country) robustly show that subjects across the Globe respond with stronger preferences for dominant leaders when they find themselves in contexts of intergroup conflict. Moreover, the intergroup conflict condition and the no-conflict condition move preferences for leader dominance in opposite directions (compared to the neutral control condition) although with the former having twice the effect size of the latter. Finally, countries’ baseline preferences for dominant leaders vary (in the neutral condition) as do the size of the experimental effects. Possible explanations for these country-level differences are explored.
In total, the project presents novel insights about followership psychology with implications for trait-based electoral behavior and leader evaluations in democracies and autocracies alike. However, most importantly it provides unprecedented support for the notion of a universal and context sensitive human followership psychology.

Authors