Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Appearance and the Success of Attorneys in Federal Court

Thu, September 30, 12:00 to 12:30pm PDT (12:00 to 12:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Psychologists believe that physical appearance is one of the most widely used heuristics that people use every day to aid in their decision making. Humans use others' appearance as a short cut to make a judgment on qualities that are difficult to observe. As a result, better-looking people often enjoy advantages when it comes to employment decisions, receiving attention from medical doctors, and earning higher grades in school. But what about in a court of law? In this paper, I test if an attorney's appearance can lead them to be a more successful advocate at the US Courts of Appeals. I theorize that a highly rated appearance can serve as a signal of desirable qualities that judges seek in an attorney’s argument, such as a coherent legal theory, proper treatment of precedent, and ideological agreement with the judge's preferences. Thus, when compared to an otherwise similar opponent, an attorney with a highly rated appearance will be more likely to win a case than an attorney with a lowly rated appearance. I test my hypothesis with a dataset of cases that received oral argument at the US Courts of Appeals from 2017-2019. After using a sample of survey respondents to rate the participating attorneys on several dimensions related to their appearance, I find support for my hypothesis. The implications of this result are stark. Not only does this finding raise serious normative implications, but it also speaks to the growing need to adjust traditional models of judicial behavior to account for judges’ preconceived biases.

Author