Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Summer 2020’s Black Lives Matter protests over the murder of George Floyd spurred many white Americans to begin to consider how they can help dismantle systems of white supremacy. When a few of the protests turned into riots a sustained conversation over the acceptability of violence began to emerge and cause fissures within white responses to the protest movement as a whole. In this paper, I consider how Abraham Lincoln and John Brown—two of the most important figures in the history of white America’s opposition to white supremacy—approached these questions. Though significant differences exist between these two men, I argue, that there is a surprising, and little noted, convergence between their approaches to violence, democracy, and opposition to white supremacy. By recovering this convergence this paper suggests a path that can help reconcile moderate and radical white opposition to racial injustice in a way that can help in the dismantling of systems of white supremacy. Lincoln and Brown are almost always presented—by both their supporters and critics alike—as occupying two competing poles of nineteenth-century white American opposition to slavery. Indeed, Brown was perhaps the most radical abolitionist white America ever produced; he killed in the name of ending slavery and sought to establish complete racial equality. By contrast, Lincoln’s initial moderation in the face of slavery has long been the source of some of his most effusive praise and damning criticism. Despite these conflicting legacies, however, there was a moment during the midst of the Civil War in which the two men were seen as compatriots by Northerners, Southerners, Union troops, and even Lincoln himself. As the war raged the fact that both men made the fateful and paradoxical choice to take up arms against their fellow citizens in the name of freedom and democracy brought them together in the minds of Americans on all sides. This paper recovers the political thought behind the moment when these two figures were widely seen as deeply intertwined. By examining how they each justified this choice and defended the democratic legitimacy of their actions the paper shows that the identification of Lincoln with Brown was not a matter of mere political expedience, done for the sake of rallying the troops, but was rooted in a real commonality between their approaches to violence, democracy, and white supremacy. In doing so, I show, that contrary to received opinion, we can at once affirm Brown’s radical stance for racial equality and Lincoln’s moderate statesmanship. This paper offers three contributions to the study of American Political Thought. First, by offering a careful reconstruction of several of John Brown’s political writings—including his defense of his actions at Harpers Ferry as well as the Constitution and Declaration of Independence he helped draft for his planned insurrectionary state—this paper rehabilitates the political insight of a critical antebellum actor whose thought has often been neglected or simply reduced to religious extremism. Second, by comparing Brown’s justifications for violence to Lincoln’s own, my paper presents a path of reconciliation between two figures whose conflicting legacies reverberate in the tensions that still exist between radical and moderate approaches to racial justice. Third, my paper surfaces two powerful attempts by Americans to address, both in theory and practice, a basic problem in democratic theory and political philosophy more generally: When, if ever, can violence be justly used against one’s political opponents?