Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Emotional Landscape of American Politics

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Emotions are the catalysts of political behavior, helping to shape how we learn about and engage in politics (e.g., Gadarian and Albertson 2014; Valentino et al. 2011).. Yet, different emotions can have different effects on our behavior, such as whether to seek out (anxiety) or avoid information (disgust), defect from our party (anxiety) or vote loyally (anger), or to support welfare policies (sadness) or oppose them (anger). Clearly, knowledge of who experiences which emotions and when is crucial to understanding political behavior.

Existing scholarship offers a variety of expectations about the political causes of emotion. Some scholars have speculated that certain issues might elicit specific types of emotions. For example, “some issues may be inherently threatening,” generating fear and anxiety (Gadarian and Albertson 2014, 134). As another example, research on disgust offers more specific expectations, suggesting that the emotion is primarily a response to issues involving health, sexuality, and outgroups. But some people may be more or less inclined to experience these emotions. For example, influential theories of political ideology hold that conservatives are more prone to experiencing negative emotions, such as fear, anxiety, and disgust (Hibbing, Smith, and Alford 2014; Jost et al. 2003). Taken together, existing research offers a rich set of expectations about who will experience which emotions in response to which political topics.

In spite of the importance of the topic and rich theory that has been developed, we have little systematic evidence as to the experience of political emotions. Scholars typically proceed by selecting a single issue that is theoretically relevant to their research question, then conduct a study focusing on that single issue. For example, under the expectation that disgust is a common reaction to health threats, a researcher might examine the effects of disgust on learning about an epidemic (Clifford and Jerit 2018). While this approach is useful for testing hypotheses about the effects of emotions, it leaves us without broad and generalizable knowledge of emotional responses to politics.

In this paper, we overcome these limitations by systematically studying which issues elicit which types of emotions, and who is most likely to experience those emotions. To do so, we use a novel topic-sampling approach (Clifford, Leeper, and Rainey 2019). Specifically, we first developed a population of topics from publicly-available polling, then randomly sampled 50 policy questions from that population. Then, in a series of studies, respondents were randomly assigned to report their emotional responses to a random subset of these topics. Using hierarchical modeling, we are able to make a number of novel and generalizable claims about the experience of emotion in politics. First, we find that enthusiasm is the most commonly experienced emotion, followed by anxiety and anger, then by sadness and disgust. Second, we find that these emotional responses vary by policy category. For example, while anxiety was the most common emotional response to foreign policy, enthusiasm was the most common response to economic policy. Finally, in contrast to influential theories of political ideology, we find only weak evidence that – on average, across a large sample of issues – liberals and conservatives have different emotional responses to politics. Taken together, our findings offer new insights into the causes of emotion, improve the generalizability of emotion research, and suggest new avenues for research.

Authors