Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Advising War: Limited Intervention in Conflict

Thu, September 30, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Why do states send military advisors and what do advisors do? To minimize the costs of intervention, great powers frequently delegate war to local partners. However, these local partners often act against their sponsor’s interests and lack the military capacity to achieve their sponsor’s goals. I argue that to manage these relationships with their local partners, great powers frequently rely on an overlooked tool of alliance management: sending military advisors to work with the local partner’s military. These advisors advance great power interests through monitoring and influencing local actor behavior and building capacity. The success of military advisors depends on the quantity deployed, whether they are embedded with local units and can accompany them into combat, whether they are deployed at the strategic and/or tactical level, the characteristics of the advisors and their counterparts themselves, and the broader politics of the relationship between the intervener and its local partner. I support my argument with original quantitative data on intervention in civil wars with military advisors by the United States, Russia, China, France, and the United Kingdom from 1946-2019. I also use qualitative evidence collected from archival sources and interviews with 26 US military advisors and 1 civilian policymaker to show that states send advisors to fill these roles and advisors are aware of their roles. This paper provides the following academic and policy contributions. First, it theorizes and provides empirical support for a form of alliance management that is commonly used by powerful states but is underexplored in the literature on proxy wars and third-party intervention. Second, understanding when intervening states have more influence over local partners, and the role of military advisors as a useful tool for creating that influence, can contribute to the design of better interventions. Third, the paper highlights significant variation in how advisors are deployed and the extent to which they are actually capable of monitoring, influencing, and building capacity, cautioning that advisors are not a panacea for powerful states seeking to manage relationships with their partners.

Author