Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Organizational Semantics of Credibility in International Relations

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

When and why do decision makers prioritize the preservation of their state’s credibility when weighing foreign policy options? This question has received relatively little attention from scholars of international politics despite a large volume of research on how decision makers assess others’ credibility. Building on classic scholarship in bureaucratic politics, I argue that organizational identity affects the dimensions of credibility that bureaucrats value, the priority they place on preserving credibility, and ultimately, their policy advocacy around the use of force. Particular differences arise between military and diplomatic organizations; while military officials equate credibility with hard military capabilities, diplomats view credibility in terms of signaling reputation, or demonstrating reliability to external parties. I test these propositions using text analysis of archival documents from two digital corpora, the Foreign Relations of the United States series and Declassified Documents Online. Combining keyness testing and topic modeling results with close reading of the underlying documents, I find support for my proposition that foreign policy advisers define credibility consistent with the organizational norms and behaviors to which they are socialized. This has implications for how military and diplomatic officials’ policy advocacy concerning the use of force, which I explore more fully in my broader dissertation project.

Author