Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Shays’ Rebellion as a Clash of Republican Visions

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Despite its supposedly pivotal role in changing public opinion about constitutional reform, Shays’ Rebellion (1786-87) has received comparatively little attention from students of political thought. In this paper, I will consider the competing versions of republicanism advanced by the insurrectionary “Regulators” (traditionally seen as led by Daniel Shays) and the governing elite of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

The Regulators saw their resistance as part of the revolutionary tradition. They repeatedly pointed out that they were acting publicly as citizens, demanding the right to be heard and respected by elected officials. They believed their right to consent to their government had been taken from them and they were oppressed by laws passed for the benefit of a few. They saw themselves as “the body of the people assembled in arms” who had exhausted all other remedies. They believed that their vision of republicanism, free men independently supporting themselves and their families, free from entanglements with laws written by legislators far away and free of debts to rapacious merchants, was under mortal threat.

The ruling elite of Massachusetts put forward the view that a well-ordered political community must reflect the natural social order, one in which the people are informed by their betters, accept their leadership and avoid the deadly temptations of luxury and self-indulgence. They combined Puritan political/religious dogma with classical republican ideas about the rule of a virtuous, self-controlled elite. They believed that the proper state of government and society is calm and ordered liberty under natural leaders. Any efforts at reform or change must be directed by those leaders. Any effort by people not in the elite toward change is by definition anarchy. The people as a whole are irrational and incapable of self-control. This can be seen in efforts to paint Shays and other leaders of the Regulation as monsters planning to destroy Boston.

In this paper I ask: What does rebellion in a (supposedly) free society mean? How is the action understood by the actors, by those they are in rebellion against, and by members of the broader political community? (Contemporary examples present themselves.)

Author