Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
What happens to labor rights when a powerful U.S. corporation hostile to worker voice in shaping labor standards and that is trying to remake the retail world expands overseas? Do its anti-union posture and its low-wage precarious work practices travel with it, or are they modified by the company proactively or altered reactively in the contestation that takes place nationally or sometimes transnationally involving unions, social movements, and government regulators? This question was posed by Walmart’s large global expansion around the turn of the century, and by the company’s sheer size and ability to reshape labor standards as a private employer at massive scale and powerful buyer pushing supplier companies to continuously sell goods to it at lower cost. A similar set of questions is posed in more recent times by the company that has supplanted Walmart in many ways as a multi-dimensional threat to labor standards via its domestic and international expansion, now propelled further by Covid’s remaking of consumer habits toward online shopping. What lessons can be learned from two decades worth of research on Walmart’s global expansion and contestation around its negative impacts on labor standards and efforts to combat them and engage the company?
This study proposes to examine these issues posed by Amazon’s rapid overseas expansion in Latin America, Western Europe, and parts of Asia through the lens of the concepts of global diffusionism versus national adaptation in multinational corporation strategy and of corporate institutional embeddedness in distinct, evolving national fields of contestation related to labor and civil society agency, national rules and regulations, and, more broadly, varieties of capitalism. The author’s own forthcoming co-authored book on Walmart in Latin America has contributed to developing this perspective (1). Based on a combination of secondary literature and the author’s preliminary research on Amazon in Brazil, it will be argued that the threat posed by Amazon to labor rights and regulatory, labor, and civil society efforts to constrain the company have a combination of commonalities and differences from the experience of contestation around Walmart. Among commonalities are 1) anti-unionism as a constant that is weakly adapted to national contexts; 2) broad, multi-issue and multi-sector contestatory alliances built around corporate giants where tools of labor action and regulation are weak; and3) challenges posed to generating transnational solidarity where shared communities of fate are not generated in as immediate a way in commerce as with the global division of labor in making manufactured goods. Among differences are 1) the boundary-redefining or -defying nature of Amazon’s conglomerate, vertically integrated model (as third party platform, seller, logistics provider, retail merchant, cloud computing provider, etc.); 2) how that distinctive feature complicates action across warehouse, supermarket, IT, logistics, delivery, or other distinct types of workers with distinct contractual models, forms of union representation, and so forth; and 3) some signs in the United States that could be precursors for Amazon overseas that, for some full-time workers in fulfillment centers whose work involve interacting constantly with robots and algorithms, it may be trying to pre-empt unionization proactively through “union substitution” strategies of raising wages, increasing benefits, and investing in training.
The comparative hypothesis offered by the paper is that pushback and resistance against Amazon’s precarious conditions and resistance to collective worker voice (as opposed to docility and passivity) has varied considerably across national settings due to quite different national fields of contestation, as was true of Walmart’s quite variable labor experience across countries and global regions. In several European contexts institutionalized roles for unions and worker representation and Amazon’s reluctance to adapt to them have generated high levels of conflict (such as in Germany where Walmart too encountered pushback and exited after only eight years), contrasted with much more diffuse and sporadic conflict in the United States around Amazon. Growth in developing countries such as Brazil is still incipient, and trends are difficult to discern. But the company’s seeming insistence on diffusing home-country practices would seem to mirror patterns that led to much conflict in the legal labor claims and labor court realm at Walmart Brazil and contributed to its exit from that company after a quarter century.
1) Scott B. Martin, Joao Paulo Veiga, and Katiuscia Moreno Galhera, Labor Contestation at Walmart Brazil: Limits of Global Diffusion in Latin America, London: Palgrave, forthcoming, Spring 2021