Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

G.I. Joe vs Tommy Atkins: Comparison of Veterans’ Benefits in the U.S. and U.K.

Sun, October 3, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In liberal welfare regimes such as the United States and United Kingdom, benefits are often distributed to specific groups of people, or develop from specific relationships between a group and the state. Yet in the development of these two welfare states, one came from the worker and the other from the veteran. The United States dedicated the majority of their interwar and postwar state development to strengthening veterans’ protections, whereas the United Kingdom created a broader, civilian welfare state with few specific veterans’ benefits. This difference in policy direction was due to both the ideological centricity of the citizen-soldier in American rhetoric compared to the United Kingdom, and to the role of veterans’ organizations and labor unions in the policy process following World War II. Because of both ideological and institutional differences, these two fairly-similar countries responded to the demobilization of thousands of ex-servicemen in drastically different ways.
This paper relies on comparative historical analysis of British and American veterans’ benefits between 1940 and 1950 to better understand the institutional differences between each country’s welfare state. Using historical and archival documents from each period, including policy/legislative debates, newspaper sources, and organizational memos from veterans’ groups, this paper will show how the conception of the “citizen-soldier” developed in the United States to further a veteran-centric perspective in the creation of the welfare state compared to the United Kingdom in which the worker was central rather than the veteran. This argument will play out in three distinct categories of analysis: the image of the soldier in the national mythology, the strength of veterans’ organizations within the political process, and the strength of labor unions in the political process.

Author