Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
At the outset of 2021 polemics regarding widespread public skepticism about democracy have become all but mainstream. Of course, democratic theorists, radical or otherwise, have been all too aware of the manifold threats that democracy faces, in all its forms. However, in the waning days of the Trump presidency this skepticism took on new meaning as skepticism gave way to outright contempt for even the most basic democratic norms and procedures. Events such as those of January 6th, 2021 have become the subject of tremendous debate, academic and otherwise. Were the anti-democratic protestors fascists, insurrectionists, an incompetent rabble of selfie takers? This paper does not take a stance in that debate, although its substance is inchoate in the logical conclusion of the former. Rather, this paper seeks to address the fact that while some correctly oppose right-wing violence, of the sort witnessed on January 6th, still others call for reconciliation with those that enact right-wing violence, their sympathizers, enablers, apologists, and yes, even those that while denouncing such violence believe in ‘turning the page.’ This paper seeks to make a theoretical intervention into the present moment to lay bare the implications of adopting a rhetoric of reconciliation in response to political conflict. I will argue that far from making amends, healing, or even seeking legal accountability, the adoption of a rhetoric of reconciliation is about disciplining political subjects. Therefore, rather than welcoming calls for reconciliation this paper argues that academics and citizens of bodies politic alike should be wary of this rhetoric as it has been in the history of political thought to use such rhetoric to render certain actors as ‘forgivable’ while demanding others adopt a ‘forgiving’ attitude. I turn to this history to illustrate that the disciplining effects of reconciliation rhetoric, while felt in our contemporary moment, have their origins in the early theorists of state sovereignty.