Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Modern Lawmakers Advertise Their Legislative Effectiveness to Constituents

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

There are high profile examples of members of Congress touting their effectiveness to the voters by directly highlighting their Legislative Effectiveness Scores. For instance, Representative Don Young (R-AK) released a press release in February 2019 titled, “Congressman Don Young Rated Most Effective Member of Congress.” On a different stage, Senator Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) proclaimed her rating as the most effective senator in front of millions of viewers during the Democratic Presidential Debate in February 2019. These instances raise the more general question of how common is advertising effectiveness to voters? Which types of members of Congress publicize their legislative effectiveness in their communications with constituents, and in what ways do they do so?

Congressional scholars have long argued that constituents' power to hold their representatives accountable is a critical element of congressional representation. What legislators accomplish - or fail to accomplish - in Washington is an important piece of that accountability. Moreover, legislators play a role in shaping what their constituents know about their Washington work by communicating directly with their district and therefore shaping the information constituents have when evaluating them.

Using textual analysis of all House members’ official newsletters to their constituents from 2009 – 2020 (Cormack 2020), we examine how members publicize their legislative effectiveness. We show that there are different ways in which legislators advertise their effectiveness to constituents, ranging from general statements to specific actions that are consistent with the components of the LES measure. We then focus on who is most likely to communicate their effectiveness and under what conditions they do so. In general, we argue that presenting voters with information about legislative effectiveness is a valuable signal of Washington activity. First, it is a notably nonpartisan signal that can appeal to voters across party lines. As such, we argue that legislators from more marginal districts are more likely to advertise their effectiveness. Second, we contend that legislative effectiveness also signals a members’ policymaking bonafides and conveys to voters that the legislator knows how to get things done in Washington. This information is expected to be especially valuable to women and minority legislators who have traditionally been less likely to be seen as powerful actors in politics. Relatedly, we also argue that more junior members will be more likely to advertise their legislative effectiveness as a way of telling voters that despite their newcomer status, they are getting things done for the district. Finally, we assert that legislators who are more effective (i.e., who have higher LES ratings) will not only say more about effectiveness in their newsletters, but will do so in more specific ways, than their colleagues who have lower scores. This research has significant implications for how constituents hold their legislators accountable for their activity on Capitol Hill, and reveals how members themselves play an important role in developing their reputation as a more effective legislator.

Authors