Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Scholars have long considered nonprofits to be the primary contracting agents for the delivery of human services at the local level. As a result, theorizing about the nature of nonprofit-government relationships has been dominated by the concepts of principal-agent and transaction cost economics (Brown and Potoski 2003). Within these frameworks, nonprofits are viewed as more trustworthy vendors than their for-profit counterparts due to their nondistributive constraints and goal congruence, which lower transaction costs for government when they outsource services that are difficult to measure and monitor (Smith and Gronbjerg 2006). However, we posit that the scope and nature of noncontractual collaboration between these sectors have not been fully captured in academic studies (see Gazley 2008 for an exception), leading us to argue the principal-agent perspective on nonprofit-government interaction has been overemphasized.
We suspect that one of the reasons might have to do with the lack of large scale, nation-wide data on such relationships. At the local level, the ICMA’s alternative service delivery (ASD) survey has long served as the only comprehensive and longitudinal information source for empirical analyses. One severe limitation for researchers is that the ASD survey instrument does not allow responding local governments to indicate whether their external production of services via nonprofits is contractual, and thus government-nonprofit interactions are inherently principal-agent in nature. Despite the absence of this critical information, the extant literature has simply tended to assume that all nonprofit-government relationships captured by the ASD are contractual. In their effort to validate ASD survey responses, Lamothe, Lamothe, and Bell (2018) argue that such interpretations can be misleading and should be reexamined with new data collection. For example, their interview findings suggest that local governments often provide small and large subsidies through grants, hotel tax allocations, and in-kind donations to support public services provided and delivered by community-based nonprofits in the areas of elder and arts programs, as well as animal shelters. Such partnerships are generally interpreted as contractual relationships by scholars using ASD data, which is problematic.
The purpose of our study is to explore the extent of noncontractual and collaborative relationships between nonprofits and governments in delivering public services to citizens and compare that information with the ASD data in order to gauge the severity of the gap that might have been created by the latter data source. In so doing, we hope to better inform local governance and nonprofit scholars about the role of the nonprofit sector in meeting social needs at the local level.
In our data collection effort, we circulate a redesigned survey that expands the ASD instrument to include more in-depth information regarding the level/types of government’s financial contributions and the exact nature of the delivery and governing arrangements between government and nonprofit service producers. The sample is drawn from the local jurisdictions that responded to past ASD surveys and indicated that they deliver services through nonprofit service providers. The five specific service areas that we focus on are programs for the elderly, arts programs, animal shelter, homeless shelter, and drug and alcohol treatment programs. These five service areas are chosen based on their frequent use of nonprofit service delivery as indicated in past ASD survey results. Our hope is that our expanded and modified survey instrument will shed better light on the actual role of nonprofits in local governance.
References
Brown, Trevor L. and Matthew Potoski. 2003. Transaction costs and institutional explanations for government service production decisions. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 13(4): 441-468.
Gazley, Beth. 2008. Beyond the contract: The scope and nature of informal government-nonprofit partnerships. Public Administration Review 68(1): 141-154.
Lamothe, Meeyoung, Scott Lamothe, and Elizabeth Bell. Forthcoming. Understanding local service delivery arrangements: Is ICMA ASD data reliable? Public Administration Review.
Smith, Steven Rathgeb, and Kirsten A. Gronbjerg. 2006. Scope and theory of government-nonprofit relations. In The Nonprofit Sector: A Research Handbook, second edition. Walter W. Powell and Richard Steinberg, eds. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press.