Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In the late 19th century, a fierce debate about imperial federation took shape in Britain and its settler colonies. From the 1860’s until the end of World War I, politicians and intellectuals in Britain and its colonies argued about the possibility of creating a federated union of Britain, Canada, Australia, New Zealand and, in some cases, South Africa, in a single country. Interest groups such as the Imperial Federation League, the British Empire League, and the United Empire Trade League campaigned for federation, while many politicians in metropolitan Britain and its colonies opposed federation. The existing literature on this debate has primarily focused on the views of the metropole rather than those of the colonies. Prior scholarship also tends to exclusively consider economic rationales or political ones (e.g. nationalism, concerns about democracy, great power competition) for supporting or opposing federation, rather than the ways in which these reasons interact.
This project has two goals. First, it examines the political and financial sources of disagreement between the metropole and the colonies over federation, and the relationship between these mechanisms. In particular, the paper is interested in the dilemmas imperial federation created for elites in the settler colonies. We assess the ways in which the arguments over imperial federation in the colonies emulated and diverged from the debate in Britain. We test whether or not a correlation exists between the flows of capital and investment from Britain to its colonies and the arguments for and against federation that colonial officials used. In doing this, we aim to contribute to the existing literature on imperial federation in intellectual history, international development and international political economy. Specifically, we combine an empirical analysis of the economic stakes of imperial federation with a political theory analysis of the arguments made by supporters and opponents of the federal project. In doing so, it brings together the principal foci of both empirical and theoretical literature on the topic. To test this relationship, we use colonial investment data, government gazettes and the papers of political figures in the Canadian and Australian settler colonies. These figures include the Canadian founders, early Canadian Prime Ministers John A. MacDonald and Wilfrid Laurier, leaders in the Australian colonies, such as the radical politician Graham Berry and the governor of Victoria, Duncan Gillies, and Agents-General dispatched to Britain on behalf of the settler colonies, such as Andrew Clarke.
Second, this project also connects the dilemma of the relationship between economic investment and the political goals of settler elites to arguments about the Anglo-Saxon race that appeared at around the same time as the debate about imperial federation. Recent literature (e.g. Bell 2020) has examined the importance of racial accounts of Anglo-Saxon internationalism to arguments for imperial federation and closer relations between Britain and the United States. We show that these same racist arguments played a more nuanced role in the debate about imperial federation in the colonies themselves. Appeals to Anglo-Saxon racial unity were in some cases used to justify restricting settlement by members of other races - thereby furthering a political goal of some colonial elites - but these appeals also made it more difficult to justify resisting British investment in its colonies, investment which colonial officials did not always welcome.