Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Overburdened? How Immigrant Dispersal Policies Can Mitigate Public Backlash

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

With growing numbers of forcibly displaced people and their tendency to spatially concentrate, destination countries around the world consider dispersing them over their territory. While the egocentric not-in-my-back-yard syndrome (NIMBYism) predicts that dispersion will spark a public backlash, sociotropic considerations and appeals to civic fairness predict the contrary. What determines which of these countervailing forces overcomes the other?

I contend that many citizens are conflicted about hosting refugees in their local communities. On the one hand, they are willing to help their fellow citizens in sharing the national burden of refugee integration. Yet they also fear that the socioeconomic burden will be too heavy and unequally shared. Anxiety about the unknown ramifications of hosting refugees underlies some of the NIMBY syndrome. Therefore, I argue, government policy can counter NIMBYism by setting clear and fair burden-sharing mechanisms.

To test this argument, I use four survey experiments conducted in Norway and Israel. The experiments reveal that citizens are more apprehensive about immigration to their local community than to their country, and that opposition to refugee incorporation rises when natives’ understand that refugees will be resettled in their local community. This set of findings shows that NIMBYism indeed shapes public opposition to immigration. However, the results also demonstrate that citizens are more willing to take in refugees when doing so will help their fellow citizens. Moreover, citizens’ preferences regarding refugee incorporation are strongly affected by the policies that guide refugee resettlement. Specifically, refugee dispersal policies counter NIMBYism when they set clear allocation rules, such as an upper bound that limits the maximum number of refugees resettled in each local community, or proportional allocation, where the number of refugees assigned to localities is a function of the native population’s size and economic standing. These effects are substantial and politically meaningful. They increase support for refugee incorporation by 50 to 61 percent and also shape citizens’ willingness to engage and lobby their elected officials to express this position.

The analysis also reveals that the impact of dispersal policies remains significant on a subset of respondents for whom moving to proportional or upper limit allocation would increase the number of asylum seekers allocated to their own localities. This suggests that the increase in inclusionary attitudes following immigrant dispersal is not driven by material self-interest, but rather stem from civic-minded, sociotropic considerations.

The paper contributes to the growing literature on interventions that can promote inclusionary attitudes toward immigrants and refugees (Facchini, Margalit, and Nakata 2016; Adida, Lo, and Platas 2018; Kalla and Broockman 2020; Williamson et al. 2020). To date, much of this literature has focused on prejudice reduction through intergroup contact or perspective-taking. The findings presented here indicate that, beyond prejudice reduction, government policies can also mitigate exclusionary attitudes toward immigrants by fixing collective action problems that relate to immigrant admission and integration. In times of rising anti-immigrant backlash, the accumulation of evidence on different strategies that can effectively reduce exclusionary attitudes toward immigrants is valuable for the design of policy responses to mass immigration and global refugee crises.

Author