Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Violence, Democracy, and Women’s Political Rights in Latin America

Wed, September 29, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The adoption of gender quotas and parity laws in Latin America has been one of the most significant advancements for improving democracy in the region. These laws, which emerged from the Fourth Conference on Women in Beijing, have been fundamental in promoting women’s political rights, increasing the regional average of women in national parliaments to 31%. These laws are part of broader efforts to deepen democracy that have included reforms to increase marginalized groups’ representation, expand social and political rights, and make governments more responsive and transparent. As the number of women in elected office has increased, reports of violence and harassment against them have become common. This phenomenon is called ‘violence against women in politics’ (VAWIP). Despite a growing literature theorizing VAWIP, it is unclear how this form of violence relates to democratization processes and the global illiberal backlash. Studies have shown that VAWIP occurs in democracies and non-democracies, but the forms, tools, and consequences vary in ways that we do not understand yet. While violence against political actors is expected in authoritarian and semi-authoritarian regimes, one of the promises of democracy is the peaceful resolution of political differences. This paper analyzes the relationship between democracy and VAWIP in three Latin American countries: Costa Rica, a consolidated democracy; Peru, a consolidated but less stable democracy; and Bolivia, a country that is struggling between authoritarianism and democratization. Comparing different Latin American countries is useful for the study of VAWIP for three reasons: first, the all three countries have a significant percentage of women in politics at different levels. In Costa Rica, women make up 45.6% of members of the National Assembly (2020), 38.6% of councilors, and 11.1% of mayors (in 2010); in Peru, women are 26.2% of members of the National Assembly, 29.4% of councilors, and 3.9% mayors; in Bolivia, women are 53.1% of members of the Chamber of Deputies and 47.2% of Senators, 42.3% of councilors, and 7.7% of mayors. Second, VAWIP has been broadly discussed in the region since the late 1990s and has been recognized as a problem for democracy and inclusion in all three countries. Finally, in all three countries electoral authorities, women’s policy agencies or ministries, and legislatures have worked to create measures to address VAWIP, acknowledging that VAWIP is widespread and represents a serious barrier for women’s political participation on equal terms as men.
The paper uses a variety of quantitative and qualitative methods to understand the relationship between democracy and VAWIP. First, I analyzed reports on VAWIP created by women’s groups and international organizations. The reports represent the first source for understanding different manifestations of VAWIP in Latin America, how it varies, and how it relates to democracy and democratization. I complemented this information with the analysis of news reports about VAWIP in Latin America. I found important differences in how women reported VAWIP in each country. Based on these findings, I then focus on specific forms of violence present in each country and test the frequency and consequences of these actions on women’s representation. In Costa Rica, I found that women vice-mayors –an office that was explicitly created to improve the representation of women in executive offices- are frequent victims of VAWIP. I then collected resolutions by the Costa Rican Electoral Tribunal and analyzed the nature, character, and responses to these forms of violence. In Peru, I found that recall referendums are frequently used against political actors to undermine their work. I analyze a database with over 5000 recall referendum efforts initiated in Peru to understand the motivation behind these efforts, whether they are successful, and how women are affected. Finally, I use interview and archival data to analyze the nature of VAWIP in Bolivia. Through this comparison, I find that VAWIP is prevalent in all three countries but the forms VAWIP take vary. While in Bolivia physical violence is somewhat common (but not the most common form of violence), in Peru and Costa Rica perpetrators of violence use democratic institutions and procedures to undermine women’s work in politics, render them ineffective as political actors, and force them to resign. The paper also finds that VAWIP is fundamentally different from other forms of violence in politics, providing evidence to arguments that suggest it is a form of gender-based violence, not a form of gender-neutral political violence. These findings emphasize that VAWIP efforts to improve the descriptive representation of women and thus are an attack on democracy. Legal responses should emphasize the implications of this form of violence for gender equality and democracy.

Author