Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Hear Ye! Hear Me! The Freshman Effect on Oral Argument in the U.S. Supreme Court

Thu, September 30, 12:00 to 12:30pm PDT (12:00 to 12:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Oral argument in the U.S. Supreme Court is an important tool for justices to gather information and communicate their views on a case. However, little is known about whether and why there is systematic variation in the justices' activity during oral argument. In this paper, I argue that because justices who have junior status on the Supreme Court speak last at conference, they have strategic incentives to act differently during oral argument. Junior justices must use oral argument to signal their support or opposition to a case. The primary hypothesis is that justices with less tenure on the Supreme Court speak more overall during oral argument. I also hypothesize that when they do speak, junior justices use more statements than questions. Junior justices are also expected to use increased sentiment during oral argument.
For this study, I compiled a novel dataset based on using oral argument transcripts from the 2004-2018 terms at the individual justice level, with each speech episode listed separately. The statistical analysis uses text as data and includes judicial activity (the number of words spoken, the proportion of statements to questions, and sentiment) as the dependent variable and seniority as the main variable of interest. The analysis also includes a varying specification of control variables including gender, ideology, and case salience. Each of the above variables will be factored into three different regressions estimating the effect of the explanatory and control variables on each of the three judicial activity measures in oral argument. Preliminary results suggest that newer justices not only speak more on average, but they speak using more statements than their more senior colleagues. Additional planned analysis will focus on changes over time for individual justices.

Author