Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Social identity has at this point been firmly established as a guiding force in electoral behavior in American politics (Mason 2019). Either consciously or subconsciously, American voters use their partisan, religious, racial, and gender identities to forge representational connections with similarly-identifying candidates, resulting in instrumental actions like casting votes. Recent scholars have established geography and “place” as a key political identity for many voters, even (or particularly) amidst significant geographic polarization (Meredith 2013, Munis 2021, Hunt 2021). These studies have firmly established that place identity—the unique place-based connection between a voter and their home geographic area—not only continues to be relevant in American elections, but also can help candidates win over voters of the other party when that identity is shared between them. Place identity is uniquely suited to cut across partisan boundaries, even amidst conditions of peak partisan polarization (Hunt 2020).
However, these studies have either been limited to either experimental conditions or observational conditions only; in addition, they have focused too narrowly on more local or parochial offices, usually reaching only as high as governorships or the House of Representatives. In this paper, we break the latter barrier by analyzing the impact of local roots and place identity in elections for the U.S. Senate. We do so with a multi-method approach, combining experimental data from a nationally-representative survey sample (N= ~3,000) with comprehensive observational data from more than 60 years of elections to the U.S. Senate (1960-2020, n= ~1,500).
Preliminary findings from student surveys (N= ~1,000) and from initial observational data strongly indicate that local roots and place identity play significant roles even in offices as prestigious as the U.S. Senate. First, our experimental survey data presents voters with pairs of fictional open-seat candidates for office with varying local characteristics, backgrounds, and qualifications for office. Voters consistently choose local candidates at higher rates, and often cross party lines in order to do so. Second, our observational findings show that Senators and Senate candidates who have significant local backgrounds in their home states prior to representing them (for example, being born, attending school, or owning a business in their home state) run at least three percentage points ahead of those without such roots, even after controlling for factors like state partisanship, race representation, and institutional factors like tenure length and chamber leadership.
The consistent findings from both the voters’ and candidates’ perspectives constitute a significant contribution to the political geography literature, and use novel data to expand our understanding of place identity and candidate localism.