Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Our paper uses Kamala Harris as a case study to illuminate some of the complexities of race in American politics today. We analyze the language used to frame Harris’ racial identity and discuss potential political consequences of those frames. Exploring Harris’ racial identity helps to highlight important uncertainties about the racial terrain in the United States in the twenty-first century, and reiterates compelling questions about the nature of race in America.
In this research, part of a larger project, we look at how Harris herself has framed her racial identity, and we also sample the racial frames that others have used, focusing primarily on major media and organized interest groups. We consider implications for multiracial coalitions and inter-racial relations, as well at what this suggests about Asian American identity in particular.
Probably the most frequent observation made about Harris is that she can be classified as a person of multiracial background. But what are those races? Harris has identified herself as African American. More simplistic descriptions also describe her as an Asian American, but the term Harris uses is “South Asian.”
This raises many questions. Is Kamala Harris “Asian American”? Who decides? What is the relationship between racial identities? What are the consequences for coalition-building and political power? In our analysis of the framing of Harris’ racial identity, we address those questions.
There has long been uncertainty about the nature of the panethnic category Asian American. The idea of Asian American was developed in the late 1960s and early 1970s, and that identity was embraced largely by Americans of east Asian ancestry. With the extensive diversification of immigrant flows from Asian countries, there has been considerable debate over the extent to which Asian American fully encompasses South Asian Americans and others (e.g., Filipino Americans). Different histories and cultures create centrifugal forces that strain bonds which might contribute to a stronger pan-Asian American identity. However, political factors may provide counterpressures that strengthen pan-Asian ties, as Pei-te Lien noted in her groundbreaking work, The Making of Asian American through Political Participation (Temple, 2001).
Examining descriptions of Harris’ racial identity also raises the issue of the relationship between racial identities. For an individual, this can be of great personal importance, and for the United States more broadly, this can be very important for future political configurations, as growing numbers of Americans fall into categories which can be defined as nonwhite. Harris has never shied away from her South Asian heritage—indeed, in her public statements she has emphasized its importance for her—but the African American identity has clearly loomed larger than an Asian American association, at least if one measures by her own specific words. As many commentators have observed in recent years, the term “people of color” may blur more than it reveals. An examination of the portrayal of Kamala Harris’ racial identity can expand our understanding of why our analytic understanding is stunted when we rely on terms that lump disparate populations together, obscuring politically important differences.