Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Foreign military training (FMT) is a common tool of military diplomacy: nearly all countries have participated in some form of foreign military training in the modern era. Despite the prevalence of these programs, we still know little about their effects on recipient armies. In many cases, the political role of authoritarian armies raises questions of whether FMT can produce political outcomes (e.g. protest response and coups d’état) as well as military ones. In this article, I argue that foreign training affects military politics only when the training reaches a critical mass of soldiers over time to cause change in the organizational culture of the recipient. Moreover, I argue that the identity of the military assistance provider matters: only FMT from democratic providers can be expected to reduce violence against protesters or the incidence of coups.
Professional military education has become deeply internationalized, with soldiers from around the world receiving training in foreign military academies. Run by Western powers and formerly the Soviet Union since decolonization, these programs have helped educate the officer corps of virtually every developing country. Education and socialization in these systems generates a diffusion of ideas regarding political intervention, including mass protests and coups d’état. FMT is especially concentrated within a few Western military establishments, especially those of the United States and France, where transmission of liberal norms related to democracy and human rights are formally included in military curricula. In the long term, foreign military training (FMT) may facilitate the transfer of these norms, for example against using military force to suppress protests. However, authoritarian states like Russia and China have also been historically important providers of military assistance, at times directly competing with NATO providers for influence over developing armies.
A number of studies have investigated the effects of foreign training on military political behavior. Some have searched for large direct effects (for example, American training causing democratization) and, perhaps unsurprisingly, found no consistent effect (Taylor 2014). But other recent studies have pushed the theory beyond an implied contact theory (i.e., “Westernizing” foreign officers’ behavior by putting them in a Western classroom for a while) to specify other causal pathways connecting FMT to military behavior. Savage and Caverley (2017) study the effect of FMT on coup propensity and find that FMT actually increases coup risk by strengthening the military relative to the regime. Soeters and Van Ouytsel (2014) argue that FMT can lead to significant organizational change in the target military, but only when intergenerational shifts occur. Both of these studies greatly advance the literature on this question by defining the causal process connecting FMT to changes in military behavior.
This article uses a mixed method approach to determine the conditions under which doctrine is transferred between trainers and trainees. I present a new dataset of military assistance providers, coding whether developing armies receive significant assistance from NATO-aligned democracies, the USSR/Russia, China, or some combination thereof. I combine a quantitative analysis with case studies of several Arab armies to trace the effects of FMT qualitatively. Results suggest that relatively short training experiences of one or two years in France or the United States can instill an understanding and appreciation of Western military doctrine and civil-military relations. In military organizations where a majority of ranking officers share a common background of substantial Western training, notions of civilian control and concern for human rights may reach a critical mass and begin to change the organizational culture.