Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Responses to the Huawei 5G Controversy: Policy in Germany, Japan, and the UK (Pre-Recorded)

Sun, October 3, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The Chinese company Huawei’s promise of affordable 5G network technology has presented several U.S.- allied democracies with a policy dilemma. On the one hand, the governments of these countries have received warnings from the U.S. government and from their own experts of the security vulnerabilities that Huawei equipment could introduce into their domestic networks. A decision to allow Huawei equipment into certain national systems could also imperil intelligence sharing and other security cooperation with the United States. On the other hand, these governments have perceived implicit or explicit threats of retaliation from the Chinese government for measures that would restrict Huawei’s access to their domestic markets. Among other reprisals, these countries’ leading exporters could see their access to the Chinese market curtailed. The governments of Germany, Japan, and the United Kingdom have faced a similar form of this policy dilemma presented by Huawei equipment, but have responded to it in distinct ways. Japan acted early to restrict Huawei’s role in supplying 5G technology. The UK at first allowed Huawei’s limited participation, but then reversed itself. Germany continues to deliberate Huawei’s partial access as domestic political opposition to the company’s role in 5G grows. This paper analyzes the three countries’ different responses over time and proposes an explanation for this unexpected variation. The analysis reveals that the drivers of these distinct responses lie not in given features of Huawei equipment, economic considerations, or security ramifications, but rather in shifting perceptions of China as a global actor since 2018. These changing perceptions have guided how the three governments have interpreted and assessed the manageability of risks associated with the emergent technologies of 5G. As this analysis demonstrates, explanations that draw a contrast between ostensibly “technical” factors and putatively “political” ones in policy outcomes obscure the irreducible enmeshing of technical judgment, political deliberation, and predictions about technological change. In contrast, drawing on theory and methods from the transdisciplinary field of Science and Technology Studies, this comparative study of three national responses reveals how political actors with distinct forms of expertise compete for authority in the 5G policy space, each proposing imagined technological futures to compel action in the present.

Authors