Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Collective Implications of Isolated Environmental Decisions: Theory & Practice

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

New environmental crises are appearing ever faster: there were six years between Silent Spring (1962) and The Population Bomb (1968), and only six months between the IPCC’s special report on 1.5 degrees of global warming (December 2018) and the IPBES’s global biodiversity assessment predicting a million extinctions (May 2019). What these accelerating environmental challenges have in common is this: they all reflect the gap between discrete moments of decisionmaking and their collective implications. The most serious problem with contemporary environmental decisionmaking is lack of coordination across multiple dimensions.

This fragmentation occurs across many domains: of time (balancing intragenerational with intergenerational justice), of space (balancing local control of environmental policy with responsibility for its general effects), of membership (balancing respect for volunteer consultation participants with the consequences for those left unrepresented), and of decision-making level (balancing encouragement of pro-active local planning with concerns for equity across localities and regions). Our fragmented decision processes mean that key values and stakeholders are routinely neglected: we discount the future, ignore externalities, focus exclusively on those at the decision table, and so forth. Without a mechanism to ensure that the long-run, generalized outcomes of fragmented series of discrete decisions are taken into account, even decisions made with the best intentions will likely lead to outcomes none of the decision-makers would have endorsed.

This paper analyses three theoretical responses to the problem of fragmented decisionmaking—Philip Pettit on policy resilience, George Akerlof on time inconsistency, and Elinor Ostrom on commons problems—and applies them to concrete challenges in environmental decisionmaking like land-use policy, adaptation to sea-level rise, and carbon budget allocation. Recognising that the inverse of the problem of coordination—the problem of local environmental agency—must also be taken into account if solutions are to be resilient, legitimate, and even just functional, the paper also investigates modes of bottom-up environmental governance. Ultimately, the aim of the paper is to provide a general theory of environmental decisionmaking that can respond to the distinctive dysfunctions we face in environmental policy and suggest principles for best practice decisionmaking.

Author