Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Effective Disoccupation

Tue, September 28, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

In international law, the doctrine of effective occupation was developed by imperial and colonial powers to justify their sovereignty over newly annexed territories. Effective occupation was measured by two criteria. First, the state must show animus occupandi, that is, the right will or intention to be sovereign over the territory. To this must be added the corpus occupandi, to wit, the concrete, actual exercise of sovereignty to mark presence in the territory, an exercise that must be continuous and appropriate to the circumstances. But what counted as the proper animus and the proper corpus?
At the basis of the doctrine of effective occupation lied, as many decolonial and postcolonial theorists have pointed out, an assumption about what sovereignty meant and required. Just like in the Lockean theory of property it is land labored in the British, agricultural way that counts as the paradigmatic case of land rightfully owned, here it was only territory governed by institutions and legal systems akin to the European that counted as effectively occupied. This narrow definition of sovereignty allowed for the dispossession and loss of control of the native inhabitants over the lands that the European colonized. For the defender of the British empire, John Westlake, this made all the sense in the world: “Because the native does not possess the concept of sovereignty, he cannot transfer it: a stream cannot rise higher than its source” (Westlake 1910, 123–24). As Martti Koskenniemi has critically commented on Westlake’s claim: “Seldom has the adage about the connections between knowledge and power been more graphically illustrated: possession of land was a function of possessing a concept” (Koskenniemi 2001, 14:138–39).
The morally outrageous implications of this narrow concept of sovereignty for the subjected peoples were denounced with increasing force especially since the second half of the twentieth century, giving way to a process of global decolonization that raised the number of states from less than a hundred in the 1950s to 195 today, and counting. Yet, even though imperialism and colonialism justified upon the concept of effective occupation are no longer acceptable when it comes to the government of peoples, they remain the default when it comes to the governance of natural resources. In fact, when it comes to the governance of natural resources there is no disagreement between ex imperial and colonial powers and newly independent states: they all take for granted that whoever effectively controls the territory effectively controls its resources. The nonhuman, natural world is thus considered ours to appropriate and use (and overuse and abuse).
In the 1960s and 1970s, the Doctrine of Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources was thought to be the main recipe to move states from poverty to wealth. Increasingly, however, the troubling effects of states’ effective occupation of the nonhuman, natural world are staring us in the face. Climate change and the biodiversity crisis are the two and most obvious examples.
In this article, I propose a transition from effective occupation to effective disoccupation when it comes to the nonhuman, natural world. Effective disoccupation may be measured by two criteria. First, states must show animus disoccupandi, that is, the right will or intention to give up Permanent Sovereignty over Natural Resources and to replace it with Permanent Trusteeship. To this must be added the corpus occupandi, to wit, the concrete, actual exercise of trusteeship over the territory.
We must engage in this transition, I claim, if we have self-interested reasons in keeping the earth inhabitable for present and future humans. But we also should engage in this transition: the more we learn about our place on earth among others, the more obvious it is that an ethics and, by extension, a political philosophy that does not take those others into account (not just on instrumental grounds) is inadequate and wanting.
In the first part of the article, I present the doctrine of effective occupation as traditionally understood and how it was challenged, giving rise to the decolonization of peoples around the world. In the second part, I suggest that effective occupation is still very much alive and in need of being challenged to decolonize the nonhuman, natural world. In the third part I propose what effective disoccupation would entail and why we both must and should move in its direction. I address objections in part IV, and conclude.

References

Koskenniemi, Martti. 2001. The Gentle Civilizer of Nations: The Rise and Fall of International Law 1870–1960. Vol. 14. Cambridge University Press.

Westlake, John. 1910. International Law, Volume I. Second ed. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Author