Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Differential Adoption Across One Nation: Vocational Education Reforms in Spain

Fri, October 1, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Suffering a major skill gap, an alarmingly high level of youth unemployment and school drop-out rates (one of the highest in the EU and the OECD), Spain undertook a set of education reforms within the last decade. Against this backdrop, the reforms on Vocational Education and Training (VET) adopted in 2013 constitute a major institutional shift in the Spanish education system. Following decades of discussions as to the need of reforms, the 2013 Law introduced significant changes in VET, facilitating earlier access to secondary-level VET, introducing a dual system that incorporates in-firm training and firms’ active involvement into the VET. These reforms bolstered enrolments in secondary-level VET schools by 90% between 2014 and 2019 (CEDEFOP 2015).
Enquiring about the coalitional basis of the recent VET reforms, this paper examines the making of these reforms and explores the ways in which they have been adopted across different autonomous regions in Spain. By using the tenets of historical institutionalism regarding a power-distributional perspective in explaining institutional change, we seek to answer the following research questions: What explains the timing of these reforms, considering the key actors such as the representatives of labor, business and teachers, as well as the incumbent political parties at both national and regional levels? What accounts for the formation of coalitions that facilitated the enactment of recent VET reforms?
The competences over the education policy in Spain are split between the national government and the regional governments. National laws set the basic standards, whilst the regional governments are endowed with the authority to add up to the national legislation with “development laws,” as they are called. Bestowed with financial autonomy, regional governments have the discretion to implement educational policy within the boundaries of national standards.
To unfold how the institutional changes in VET are adopted in different ways across Spain, we focus on three regions that vary regarding the scope of the reforms, industry, unemployment levels (24% in Andalucia, 10% in the Basque Region and 13% in Madrid) as well as the broader landscape of organized non-state actors and political coalitions. For instance, the 2013 Law sets forth a minimum of one-third of all training activities of VET students to be carried out as in-firm training. However, the Madrid Region adopted a system of fifty-fifty to be spent at school and in the firm, surpassing the legal minimum set by the national legislation. The Basque Region came up with a broad range of additional standards and comprehensive measures. Whereas, Andalusia lacks such comprehensive adoption.
What explains the cross-regional diversity in embracing the 2012-2013 reform and incorporating new layers at the regional level? How do existing institutions and practices in VET at the regional level filter the ways in which VET reforms are adopted in different autonomous regions? How regional coalitions across non-state actors (organized labor, teachers and businesses) as well as those between non-state and state actors at the regional level intermediate the design and adoption of VET in the autonomous regions? This paper suggests that such variation is a product of existing institutional set-up and practices regarding VET, the type of industries present in respective regions; and the nature of reform coalitions.
Presence of shared rules of the game at the national level, yet the prevalence of partial autonomy at the regional level in education policy makes Spain an apt case study to analyze cross-regional variation in adopting VET reforms. This institutional set up facilitates to identify how policy contexts in different autonomous regions give rise to diverging modalities of VET adoption, generating lock-in effects, setting constraints on future reform initiatives, in line with power-distributional equilibria among a broad set of actors. As ‘placing politics in time’ matters (Pierson 2004), we consider timing and sequencing important on their own in analyzing the varying breadth and depth of reforms, undertaken by distinct coalitions of actors.
Triangulating tools of qualitative research (in-depth interviews, text analysis of official documents), this paper investigates the adoption of VET policies in Spain in the last 25 years. The interviews are conducted with politicians, education bureaucrats (of the Ministry of Education at the national level and Departments of Education at the regional level), representatives of labor, employers and teachers. Process tracing will be carried out to analyze the data, assessing the diverging reform trajectories.
A clear analysis of the Spanish case, where plural VET practices have emerged within the same national framework, might shed light on the varying modalities and degrees of VET adoption, particularly pertinent to federal systems and/or education systems with decentralized governance.

Authors