Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Lot of Cyber Fizzle, but Not a Lot of Bang

Fri, October 1, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Within both practitioner and scholarly communities, there is an unresolved debate about the escalatory effects of cyber operations. On one hand, pessimists look at the increase in offensive cyber operations across countries, as well as a transition to an overtly offensive cyber doctrine within the US, as a sign of the obvious escalatory effects of cyberspace. On the other hand, however, many scholars point to the lack of violent responses to cyber operations as evidence that not only are cyber-operations not escalatory, but as evidence that cyber operations may actually de-escalate conflict. We use a crisis wargame to test these opposing hypotheses, examining the use of cyberspace operations across a game series played over two years with 500+ players. We find that, despite an overall increase in cyber operations from earlier research based on wargames, cyber operations still have little influence in the overall violence of games--suggesting that both sides are correct. Cyber operations show an increasing amount of fizzle, but not a lot of bang.

Authors