Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Why do secessionists win overwhelming support in referenda nearly everywhere except in the most economically prosperous regions? This project shows that the key reason is the presence or absence of private big business, a unique social actor with the incentive, the power, and the legitimacy to oppose secession. Where big business is present, it makes the debate about the economic consequences of secession less one-sided, resulting in split electorates. In the absence of private enterprise, public debate is far more one-sided, favouring the secessionists.
These hypotheses find support in a qualitative comparison of three cases featuring private big business – Catalonia (2017 or 2015 election), Scotland (2014), and Quebec (1980 and 1995) – and two cases where that actor was absent – Slovenia (1990) and Western Australia (1933). In the first three, between 40 and 50% of the population supported independence. In the last two cases, support was much higher, 66 and 95% respectively. The comparison combines historical data and interviews with content and discourse analysis. It supplements the largely qualitative work with the results of a 2020 survey experiment conducted in Scotland. The data shows that voters are more likely to trust business figures than politicians when it comes to evaluations of the future costs of secession.
While the theme of this project is secession, it has important implications for our understanding of democracy. By exploring the role of social power in shaping opinion over highly contentious issues, it shows that democracy requires more than just fair institutional rules. Genuine competition of ideas, and thus genuine democracy, requires multiple poles of social power.