Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Almost a century ago, in the late spring of 1924, the US Congress constructed one of the most consequential weeks in the history of US citizenship. Only a few days apart, it passed the Immigration Act, which set strict national origins quotas on who could enter, and the Indian Citizenship Act, which ended a century of piecemeal, ad hoc citizenship policy towards Native Americans by decreeing all of them to be US citizens overnight, whether they wanted to be or not. While both of these pieces of legislation have been the subject of scholarly inquiry and analysis, the juxtaposition of the two has yet to be explored (on the Immigration Act, see: Higham 1955, Nagi 1999, Makela 2003, on the Indian Citizenship Act, see: Stein 1972, Bruyneel 2004).
This paper is the first work which compares the two pieces of legislation and places them in historical context, highlighting the summer of 1924 as a critical juncture in the development of American citizenship. It draws on a content analysis of congressional debates leading up to the passage of these two acts, and archival research at the Calvin Coolidge Presidential Library. The paper asks, what can we learn about the development of American citizenship from the fact that the same political moment seemingly produced such extreme gestures of openness and closure?
This paper contributes to the literature on nativism, which is almost entirely focused on anti-immigrant sentiment, by putting it in conversation with the literature on Native American assimilationism. Understanding them both as elements of the nationalist construction of American citizenship helps to illuminate the cultural project of Americanization as deeply white supremacist. For example, in 1921, when he was still vice President, Calvin Coolidge who later became the president who signed both pieces of legislation, said: “We have a great desire to be supremely American. That purpose we know we can accomplish by continuing the process which has made us Americans.”
Rather than sitting in tension with one another, then, this paper argues that these two acts were complementary moves towards enhancing the “embrace” of the American state (Torpey 2000). In other words, developing the capacity to control, classify, and identify citizens was deeply linked to the crystalizing territoriality of the United States in that time period, serving as mutually reinforcing steps towards domination of the continent from one end to the other, both physically and culturally.
I would be very happy to present this paper on a historical panel, a panel about nativism, or a panel about the concept of citizenship more broadly.