Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Prisons in America: Tocqueville and Beaumont on Democracy’s Carceral Boundaries

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

On May 11, 1831, Alexis de Tocqueville and Gustave de Beaumont stepped onto American soil in Newport, Rhode Island. The pair of Frenchmen had been sent by their government to study the American prison system, and to report back with suggestions for penal reform in France. The pair toured fourteen different American prisons, speaking to inmates, prison officials, and others with knowledge of the American penal system. They remained in the U.S. until sailing back to France on February 20, 1832. On the Penitentiary System in the United States and its Application to France was published in 1833 and subsequently translated into English.

It is not a coincidence that alongside Beaumont, Tocqueville, the sage of American democratic life, came to America not to study democracy but to study prisons instead. In this paper, I read Tocqueville and Beaumont’s prison writing to shed light on how the prison functions as a kind of democratic boundary-making device. On the one hand, the prison restricted the bounds of democratic participation, barring those inside from voting, from serving on juries, and—amid the rise of solitary confinement, a practice Tocqueville and Beaumont championed—from participating in politics alongside others. And yet on the other hand, these penitentiaries were themselves created by democratic reformers. Their aim, as I read Tocqueville and Beaumont, was to enhance democratic self-rule. I argue that the prison thereby functions as a porous democratic boundary, both fostering and restricting democratic politics.

The paper begins with an overview of On the Penitentiary System, outlining the book’s structure, approach, and interventions into a wide-ranging debate between duel models of penal reform. I then examine how Tocqueville and Beaumont saw the prison as a democracy-enhancing institution, created by the people to advance democratic ideals of reform. By teaching religious values and promoting literacy, these new penitentiaries shaped better-prepared democratic citizens. Next, I explicate the other side of that democratic boundary: the ways in which the penitentiary restricted self-rule. Disenfranchised from voting, barred from jury service, and restricted from political participation, penal institutions functioned as an important border of who counts in democratic life. Prisons in Tocqueville and Beaumont’s America were antidemocratic spaces—yet designed and promoted by democratic reformers for democratic reasons. They illustrate the connection between our democratic and carceral impulses.

Author