Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The New White Visibility: Framing Whiteness in the Post-2016 Era

Sat, October 2, 7:30 to 8:00am PDT (7:30 to 8:00am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Since the Civil Rights Era, scholars of race and U.S. politics have identified pernicious ways that racism persists among White people in the form of new racism (e.g. Bonilla-Silva 2006), racial resentment (e.g. Kinder and Sanders 1996), and other incarnations despite racially progressive changes in policy, legislation, and social norms. In response to these persistent patterns of White racism, some activists and academics have turned away from a narrative of straightforward racial progress and toward an effort to unearth existing racism from within Whiteness. For example, political theorist Juliet Hooker (2009, 51) identifies one way to undermine racialized solidarity and the racial caste system: “making whiteness visible to whites.” Making Whiteness visible, she argues, is imperative for antiracism.

During the post-Civil Rights Era and especially the Obama era, this seemed a reasonable approach for racial justice projects: to combat the new, more insidious forms of racism among White people, we must first combat the rhetoric of post-racialism and race-blindness that allowed Whites to cloak racial animus in the narrative that they did not see race. However, since the election of President Trump and the rise of the Black Lives Matter movement, Whiteness has been made visible to Whites – in two divergent ways.

First, the Trump campaign and presidency shaped and promoted a vision of Whiteness that is based on White victimhood and the oppression of White people by social programs that help nonwhite groups – using more explicit racial appeals than any other contemporary, mainstream political candidate (Valentino, Newburg, and Neuner 2018), emboldening the far right (Müller and Schwarz 2018), and activating a dormant community of white nationalists and white nationalist sympathizers (Simon and Sidner 2018). Chants by White supremacists that “you will not replace us” and claims by participants in the Capitol insurrection that they were “stopping the steal” of the election by primarily Black, Democratic-leaning cities.

Second, the Black Lives Matter movement and various progressive responses to Trump’s presidency prompted a new White self-awareness that asks White people to recognize their racial privilege as a way to recognize and work against systemic racism, especially antiblackness (Smith 2020). Although these two frames share a rejection of the earlier postracial and race-blind rhetoric, they do so in opposite political directions.

In this paper, we investigate the effects that these diverging visions of whiteness have on Whites’ racial attitudes and their willingness to commit to antiracism. Like Hooker, we are interested in the possibility of undermining White racism and promoting White commitment to antiracism and racial solidarity. In order to test White reactions to these different frames of Whiteness, in a survey experiment we manipulate which frame White respondents see (White oppression or White privilege) and test whether respondents’ commitment to antiracist political practices or policies diverge as a result of the way in which Whiteness is made visible to them.

We also present the results of a natural experiment using polling data from 2017 around the Unite-the-Right racist marches and counter-protests that centered around a Confederate monument and resulted in the death of an antiracist protestor. In the natural experiment, which was conducted during the days before and after the Charlottesville, VA protest and attack, we demonstrate that there was an increase in White respondents’ agreement with the existence of White privilege immediately after the exogenous shock of the attack – but this increase in antiracism quickly faded. These studies have important implications for the study of Whiteness, the possibility for White antiracism, and White solidarity toward racial minorities.


Citations

Bonilla-Silva, E. (2006). Racism without racists: Color-blind racism and the persistence of racial inequality in the United States. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.

Hooker, J. (2009). Race and the Politics of Solidarity. Oxford University Press.

Kinder, D. R., Sanders, L. M. (1996). Divided by color: Racial politics and democratic ideals. University of Chicago Press.

Müller, K. and Schwarz, C. 2018. “From Hashtag to Hate Crime: Twitter and Anti-Minority Sentiment.” Available at SSRN: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3149103 . 

Simon, M. and Sidner, S. 2018. “Trump says he's not a racist. That's not how white nationalists see it.” CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2018/11/12/politics/white-supremacists-cheer-midterms-trump/index.html.  

Smith, J. June 16, 2020. “How the movement that’s changing America was built and where it goes next.” Rolling Stone. https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/black-lives-matter-jamil-smith-1014442/. 

Valentino, N., Newburg, J., and Neuner, F. 2018. “From dog whistles to bull horns: Racial rhetoric in U.S. presidential campaigns, 1984 – 2016.” Paper presented at the 2018 annual meeting of the American Political Science Association.

Authors