Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Greeks and the Goths: Radical Critiques of Victorian Civilization

Wed, September 29, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper investigates the role of competing historical ideals in late-Victorian thinkers’ critiques of the concept of civilization. Focusing on the work of Edward Carpenter, William Morris and Charles Ashbee, I offer an account of two competing ideals of uncivilized society: one based on Homeric Greece and the philosophy of Plato, the other based on medieval Europe and the politics of workers’ associations in medieval towns. I argue that these two ideals were not vague utopias, but rather detailed philosophical reconstructions of arguments in Plato and medieval philosophy, respectively. For these thinkers, barbarism was a social ideal we should aim for. Their competing historical constructions of this social ideal informed and structured the ways in which criticisms of civilization produced criticisms of empire. Carpenter’s Homeric ideal led him to offer a thoroughgoing critique of imperialism as a mechanism for spreading civilization. He also emphasized the creation of new habits as a way of overthrowing civilization. Medievalists like Ashbee and Morris, on the other hand, sought to create new political and economic institutions that would undermine civilization in Britain. Their institutionalist critiques ended up being co-opted by Fabians who sought to defend the British empire on the grounds that it preserved the preconditions for socialist institutions in Britain and its empire. Carpenter’s anti-imperialism, although often seen as unoriginal and marginal, was in fact far more thoroughgoing, and far more influential on anti-colonial politicians in the empire, than the medievalism of Ashbee and Morris.
The paper connects these competing historical ideals to a broader range of political disagreements amongst British radicals towards the end of the 19th century, including debates about racial and gender essentialism and the role of the social sciences in creating a more just world. Surprisingly, given that he is usually seen as an ethical socialist, Carpenter was more enthusiastic about the potential of the social sciences to undermine civilization than many Fabians and medievalist radicals. He argued that social science could help us understand and create better habits, but also that it could explain how seemingly essential differences between genders were actually the product of the alienation of men from both women and their own feminine virtues. For Carpenter, British civilization – and the British empire especially – promoted a sort of gendered citizenship that undermined his ideal of the good citizen as androgynous. Ashbee and Morris, on the other hand, although interested in political economy, were far more skeptical of the use of social science in pursuit of radical aims.

Author