Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Enterprising Extremists-Crime, Religion & the Business of Violence in Pakistan

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

As global attention and resources have shifted away from issues of extremism, conditions in many parts of the world are ripe for a resurgence of extremist violence. From former theaters of robust US military engagement like Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria to secularist strongholds like France and Turkey, incentives and opportunities for extremist violence are rising. This rise however has not been met with renewed thinking or updated conceptual or policy frameworks. In an effort to fill the gap, this work offers the concept of the enterprising extremist – a particular type of violent entrepreneur whose behavior and choices help explain trends in extremist violence. These key actors, vying for space, resources, affluence, and influence respond to changes in local incentive structures and make strategic choices about the type and timing of their violence. They are able to style and restyle their violence in the various narratives ethnic, electoral, criminal, and extremist violence. This article questions how and why violent entrepreneurs choose extremist violence instead of other violent strategies at particular times.

Drawing on extensive field research and subnational data from Pakistan, this article specifies the incentive structures that induce extremist violence, turning violent entrepreneurs into enterprising extremists. It helps explain why spikes and lulls in extremist violence occur at different times in different cities within Pakistan. The research shows that state endorsement, a particular composition of the market for violence, and the breakdown of traditional patronage networks increase incentives for extremist violence relative to other forms of violence. While the particular conditions that raise incentives for extremist violence may be different in other countries, the concept of the enterprising extremist and a framework that prioritizes incentives over ideology has analytical value for cases beyond Pakistan.

**A version of this paper will be published in Orbis – A Journal of World Affairs.
Rabia Zafar is a postdoctoral fellow at the U.S. Naval War College.

Author