Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Politically Enforced Neglect and the Politics of Methane

Thu, September 30, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The mitigation of methane invokes many potential frames beyond its near-term greenhouse gas potency. These include environmental health concerns through its contribution to air toxics through formation of volatile organic compounds and its permanent waste as a valued and non-renewable natural resource when vented or flared. Technologies to measure, monitor, capture, and use released gas are readily available and maturing rapidly, far moreso than carbon dioxide. Nonetheless, policies to mitigate methane have evolved very slowly at federal and state levels in the United States but also other federations that produce oil and gas, including Canada and Mexico. Even a 2016 continental executive agreement between federal leaders of Canada, Mexico and the United States to achieve substantial reductions has largely failed. Modest US federal regulatory efforts under the Obama Administration have been largely eviscerated in the face of intensive state and industry opposition in the Trump era while most production states have preserved accommodating decades-old regulatory regimes. Both Canada and Mexico have struggled to follow through on bold initial pledges.

This paper examines the continued inability to develop a mature and robust methane mitigation policy regime in most oil and gas producing states and provinces in North America over the last decade. It invokes Matthew Crenson’s classic characterization of “politically enforced neglect” to explore a political landscape in which climate, environmental health, and economic development problems linked to methane releases are widely evident through venting and flaring but generally struggle to reach governmental agendas and largely fail to translate into consequential sub-federal or federal policies. These factors include the formidable influence of oil and gas producing industry with legislatures and regulatory agencies, even in instances when diverse opposition coalitions emerge to push for new policy. They are compounded by the highly-decentralized and remote nature of much oil and gas production, the local fear of losing development given the increasingly mobile capacity of fossil-fuel production in the shale era, and the penchant in the fracking era to pursue rapid and short-term oil output from shale deposits that often view increasing amounts of associated gas releases as a nuisance to be ignored rather than a resource to be captured.

The paper will also examine a very small subset of sub-federal North American cases where there has been a considerable policy shift leading to significant reductions in methane emissions. Most notably, these include Colorado’s decade-long effort to elevate methane as a central state natural resource, air quality, and climate concern, culminating in a series of laws adopted in 2019-2020 that build on earlier executive-led steps and are now being implemented. These go considerably farther than any prior North American jurisdictions and model or surpass global best practice cases from Europe and the Middle East. Alberta, California, New Mexico, Pennsylvania, and Wyoming will also be considered as shadow cases, as they have developed more consequential policies than most oil and gas producing jurisdictions, albeit not with the scope of Colorado.

The paper is designed to offer a preliminary political analysis of a potent greenhouse gas that has generally been overlooked by the policy sciences in comparison with carbon dioxide. It assumes that natural gas will increasingly be phased out for climate considerations in North America but that this transition will not be immediate, making stewardship of any remaining energy production an essential part of a viable climate mitigation strategy. The analysis will conclude with comparison between oil and gas production and other sources of methane pollution, including livestock, solid waste landfills, closure and remediation of fossil fuel drilling and mining operations, and oil and gas transport via pipelines, rail and truck. Unlike urban-concentrated industrial, electricity, and transportation sources of carbon dioxide, methane releases primarily occur in rural and remote areas, nurtured by a unique infrastructure of state and local land-use regulations, accommodating regulatory commissions, industry subsidies, royalty payments to host property owners, and dependency upon local tax revenue. Methane defies blending into conventional climate policy frames, underscoring both the profound challenges to advance constructive policy in this area but also opportunities to distill lessons from exceptional emerging cases.

Author