Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Timing vs. Religious Doctrine: Secular Institutions in Comparative Perspective

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Why do some countries adopt secular institutions while others do not? Under what conditions do political organizations with a secularizing agenda succeed in removing the official role of religion from the public and private lives of individuals? This paper underscores the importance of timing in the process that leads to (or prevents) institutional secularization. In brief, we argue that the more time pro-secular organizations have before the emergence of populist religious ones, the more likely they are to succeed in their endeavours. We start with the premise that, all else being equal, secularizing political groups are at a comparative disadvantage when it comes to recruiting grassroots support because, unlike religious actors, they cannot rely on a pre-existing organization. Secularizing groups become more likely to overcome this obstacle if they have time to build a robust organization before religious political movements with a populist agenda and grassroots support emerge.

Our argument is that populist religious parties are distinct from the run-of-the-mill conservatives in their active emphasis on including the masses in politics. Unlike conservatives who are constrained by their pro-elite concerns, the populist religious parties readily use their local organizational advantages vis-à-vis the secular parties as much as possible. Hence, those secular parties that make organizational headway before the entry of popular religious parties to politics enjoy a better chance of overcoming their comparative disadvantage.

We suggest that this logic has important implications for our understanding of whether religious doctrine influences secularization of institutions around the world. Empirically, the dominance of Islam in the population correlates with relative lack of institutional secularization. Our argument suggests that the roots of the institutional difference between Muslim and Catholic contexts can be found in the relative timing of competing secular and religious populist parties. We argue that a major cause of this difference in timing and sequence was the conscious decision on the part of the Vatican to obstruct the formation of Christian Democratic movements and parties in 1830s, which significantly delayed the formation of these movements and opened a window of opportunity for pro-secular groups in Catholic countries. By contrast, this window of opportunity has not been available in most Muslim contexts, where populist pro-religion organizations, including some with a nationalist agenda, emerged around the same time as those with a secularizing agenda.

To test the argument, we use a mixed methods approach that uses comparative historical analysis of Iran and Mexico followed by statistical analysis of original historical data including all majority Muslim and Catholic countries around the world since 1830. We select Iran and Mexico for two reasons. First, these cases are matched on factors that according to the existing literature lead to institutional secularization: economic modernization and historically close throne-altar relations (beginning with late 18th century). Yet, these cases followed different trajectories in terms of institutional secularization. Second, these cases differ both on the dominant religious doctrine and the timing of secular and populist religious organizations. These differences allow us to test the empirical predictions of the arguments that emphasize doctrine against our argument on timing and comparative organizational strength. After the comparative historical analysis, we evaluate the external validity of our argument through historical cross-national analysis.

Author