Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Liberating the Enemy in South Africa’s Anti-Apartheid Struggle

Thu, September 30, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Political science scholars of nonviolent resistance tend to define it as a form of contentious politics – an adversarial strategy within an asymmetric power relationship. We tend to study nonviolent resistance based on similar assumptions about its necessarily adversarial nature, drawing on theories of violent conflict. Empirically however, dynamics of nonviolent resistance do not fit entirely within an adversarial frame. And in an era of political polarization, it is critical for scholars to explore not only how social movements deconstruct political institutions by organizing and mobilizing to undermine their target regimes’ pillars of support, but also how they constructively engage with political institutions like negotiations and elections. Social movements’ constructive and educational engagement with institutions across “enemy” lines (i.e. between movement leaders and leaders of their target regime) are sometimes explicitly incorporated into their strategic repertoire. For example, for decades, South Africa’s African National Congress (ANC) explicitly sought to liberate their opponents from “the bars of prejudice and narrow mindedness.” And ANC leaders and leaders of South Africa’s National Party government undertook secret negotiations long before the Anti-Apartheid Struggle was ripe or had reached a mutually hurting stalemate. The height of these negotiations occurred contemporaneously with the most extreme episodes of opposition-initiated violence and state-sponsored repression. This essay explains how the commitment of ANC leadership to non-racialism as matters of policy and practice underpinned these strategic decisions to liberate and negotiate with their opponents. The essay relies on newly uncovered archival material, scholarship by South African and Western academics, as well as elite interviews. And it presents a novel theory of social movement strategy that is not based on an understanding of target regime leaders having a singular identity – adversary, but as having a dual identity – adversary and potential ally. In so doing, this essay challenges scholarly assumptions about social movement strategy and provokes new lines of research about social movements and democratization.

Author