Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
For the panel “Democracy and Dictatorship,” I will present a paper on the specter of dictatorship that hovered over American politics during the so-called “critical period” between 1781 and 1787. I will demonstrate that there was widespread interest in including a magistracy modeled on the Roman dictatorship in any future constitutional arrangement, and that support came from many of the most notable writers and political actors of the period. Thus the political economist Pelatiah Webster would write in 1783 that in cases of exigency “I know of no better way than that which the Romans adopted on the like occasion, viz. that both houses meet in one chamber and choose a dictator, who should have and exercise the whole power of both houses.” Similar ideas would be advanced in this period by respected international observers, including John Dalrymple, Louis-Sebastien Mercier, and the Abbe de Mably. The question is why and how the notion of dictatorship came to suddenly recede from the American political imagination in 1787, and here I propose a new reading of the sources. As it turns out, the institution of dictatorship was pressed most vigorously by proponents of legislative supremacy, as an alternative to a permanent executive magistracy, whether a king, a Lord Protector, or a president. And it was proponents of executive and indeed of regal power—Alexander Hamilton most notably—who were most eager to warn of the dangers to liberty posed by dictatorship, and who played the essential role in its stigmatization in this pivotal decade.