Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
On January 6, 2021, in response to the riots at the US Capitol, Donald Trump Jr. tweeted to his then 6.64 million followers, “This is wrong and not who we are. Be peaceful and use your 1st Amendment rights, but don’t start acting like the other side. We have a country to save and this doesn’t help anyone.” In the days and weeks following the riots and insurrection, much of the American political commentary, statements from across the US political spectrum, and national media coverage, reflected a theme of America being ‘too special’ a nation to be experiencing such a violent attack on democracy in the nation’s capital. This paper proposes an emerging trend of American exceptionalism as denial – a process by which exceptionalist rhetoric has become central to the framing of discussions around the political violence and overt white nationalism witnessed at the events at the Capitol.
This trend marks a sharp contrast to traditional uses of American exceptionalist rhetoric, within political speeches to celebrate the impressive achievements of the United States, to endear audiences to presidential campaigns, and often used to promote or justify particular foreign policy positions to domestic and foreign audiences. In this case, instead of America’s exceptional status as a positive frame for expressing US ‘greatness’ to a cheering public, American exceptionalism becomes a negative frame that is instead used by politicians and commentators to stave off doubt in the American project, or to show that this particular event at the Capitol is but a singular, if abhorrent, event in the continuing progress of an ‘ever perfect union’. The violence seen on January 6th 2021 is, through these eyes, “not who we are.”
This paper pursues a method of Rhetorical Political Analysis to understand how the presidential administration (and broader executive branch), legislators from both sides of the aisle, and media commentators draw on the rhetoric of American exceptionalism to both denounce the events at Capitol, express their shock and disbelief, and to frame their arguments for how these events came to take place. Within this analysis, the events and commentary from these same actors from the November Presidential Election onward are considered, in order to contextualise the later political rhetoric.