Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

When Does Descriptive Representation Backfire?

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

India is the world’s largest democracy and the developing world’s most enduring. In the past several decades India has made significant advances in the political representation of a range of marginalized groups, including, women, scheduled castes, scheduled tribes, and religious minorities such as Sikhs and Christians. Yet, Indian Muslims remain underrepresented in politics and their representation has been decreasing over the past ten years. Today, 14.2% of Indians are Muslims (or about 200 million people) while less than 5% of members of parliament are Muslim. Even at the state level, Muslims lag in terms of representation. For example, in Uttar Pradesh, the state with the largest number of Muslims in India (19.2%), only 6% of members of the legislative assembly are Muslim. This paper considers one driver for Muslim political underrepresentation: voter backlash from descriptive representation.

Research across a wide range of contexts demonstrates the positive effects that descriptive representation can have for marginalized groups. From increasing voter turnout among Black Americans to mobilizing Indian women into the political arena, descriptive representation can be an important channel for the political empowerment of marginalized groups.

With a focus on Indian Muslims, this paper argues that descriptive representation can also generate backlash against marginalized group members that can reverse their political gains. Using state and national election data and a regression discontinuity design in India’s largest state (Uttar Pradesh), I show that electing a Muslim representative generates backlash that lowers the likelihood of electing Muslim candidates in the future. To better understand the process of backlash to descriptive representation I examine a set of mechanisms that drives backlash among voters and explore which types of Muslim politicians generate the highest amounts of backlash. This project will theoretically and empirically expand our understanding of political representation of marginalized groups in the context of the largest and one of the most religiously divided democracies in the world.

Author