Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

What Are They Doing Right? Tweeting Rightwing Intersectionality in Latin America

Sun, October 3, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper builds on our curiosity around the capacity of current conservative voices to persuade and inspire. In a context where the Latin American right is reclaiming the public debate with significant gains, we focus on one significant feature of conservative politics that has not been explored enough: the simultaneous attack on the left, feminism, and the social diversity agenda. We argue that this both mirrors and reverses ‘intersectionality’ and thus call this political narrative right-wing intersectionality (RWI).
Intersectionality (Crenshaw, 1989) is an approach to research that entails the acknowledgment and exploration of the multidimensional character of power and the connections between race, class, gender and other axes of social positioning and inequality. As such, the approach has complexified the critical analysis of society and politics. RWI embodies a conservative form of activism that is intersectional in its own way: its defense of racial, gendered and class hierarchies is performed through a simultaneous attack on the different theories and movements that challenge them.
RWI meshes the old cold-war rhetoric against Marxism (Ravecca, 2015; Scirica, 2014) with the current conservative angst around feminism (Faludi, 1991; Dragiewicz, 2008; Segato and McGlazer, 2018; van Wormer, 2008). The blend is not new and in fact RWI updates old attempts of depicting the women’s movements as a trojan horse for communism (Valobra, 2014). Nowadays the main targets are feminist and LGBTQ scholarship and activism and the political gains they achieved in the last years (Pérez Bentancur and Rocha-Carpiuc, 2020). They are depicted as a transnationally organized enemy that undermines the very fabric of Western Civilization.
RWI’s agents are not typical or mainstream right-wing politicians. In its ranks we find evangelical pastors, Catholic opinion leaders and activists as well as young social media influencers. The link to Christian conservatism is clear. However, RWI is articulated in secular or even in scientific language as well. This makes it palatable for broader audiences. Furthermore, some movements such as Con mis hijos no te metas in Peru or Escola sem Partido in Brazil have successfully entered the institutional arena, affecting public policy and legislation. This public legitimization of RWI’s extreme views has been facilitated by social media, and the role of the latter in the politics of the region seems to be increasing (Segado-Boj, Díaz-Campo and Lloves-Sobrado, 2015; Aruguete and Calvo, 2018). Platforms like WhatsApp and Twitter have been instrumental for ultra conservative discourse dissemination in Latin America.
In this paper we define RWI and show how the extreme right in Latin America uses it to influence public debates and leverage political power and public opinion. We concretely address two questions: how is RWI used to create new political identities that resonate with wide publics? And how this is done through Twitter, as the privileged space for politics on social media? We start by further conceptualizing RWI. We then situate it within right-wing politics in Latin America and expand on the centrality of the notion of gender ideology in its script.
The empirical analysis employs a mixed-methods approach. The study is based on 30,858 tweets by a purposive sample of 20 leading activists and politicians from Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Ecuador, Mexico, Paraguay, Peru, and Uruguay. We show how the narrative of RWI works by identifying the presence of, and correlation between, theoretically significant terms as well as the emotions attached to them. The exploration was conducted for each one of the individuals, but we offer an aggregated analysis of the whole sample. The evidence proves our argument and clearly illustrates RWI. To further specify the findings, we focus on the discourse of three activists. Furthermore, throughout we interpretatively (Geertz, 1997) engage with tweets that exemplify RWI. We conclude that RWI is both theoretically and politically significant and urge critical scholars to take it seriously.

Authors