Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
He is without voice. Twitter said your tweets break the rules and you will not be able to tweet for 12 hours. They claimed they hoped the president would learn. He did not and Mr. Trump's access to Twitter was permanently cancelled. For a person who spent many hours every day communicating via Twitter it was an end to his voice. In the first days after being cancelled he only posted a couple of videos speaking to the nation.
Donald Trump is not absent from Twitter. Twitter did not bar mention of the departing president. They ruled only that he could not act on Twitter. @RealDonaldTrump was no longer an account on Twitter. When he tried various alternate routes -- user identifications -- they dropped those as well. Tweets mentioning Mr. Trump remain abundant on Twitter with other users referring to him in their tweets.
So what is to be the impact of Twitter refusing to permit Donald Trump to use their service? That is the question we will address in this research.
We can detail Trump on Twitter for many months before his account or accounts were cancelled. We have collected tweets by Trump or mentioning Trump in two ways. We collected tweets containing a reference to Trump through the Twitter streaming API for more than a year. Generally that search found 700,000 to 800,00 tweets a day with a few days more and a few days less. We also collected a network of tweets that mention, reply to or retweet Trump using the program NodeXL daily from the time Biden became the Democratic candidate until Twitter stopped Trump’s use of the service. That is many fewer tweets a day, but they are tweets that were selected to constitute a network of communication. We will continue these data collections for another 6 months to trace the history of Trump on Twitter after @RealDonaldTrump was canceled.
One set of comparisons seem obvious. How many tweets each day after the cancellation compared to before the cancellation. We already know that in the first days after cancellation tweets referring to Trump have not declined, but this is written just as his 4 years concluded. A second comparison is changes in individuals posting messages referring to Trump. We have names and user accounts of individuals who posted the tweets that can be compared over time. For other research we have looked at frequency of tweeting over time and find that can be compared from one twitter stream to another.
For the network collections we can examine change in the structure of the networks. The structure may be decentered after @RealDonaldTrump’s cancellation. There are two ways it could happen. One, the networks are divided into groups with particularly close communication. Before cancellation the groups in the networks may be more concentrated by having a higher percentage of individuals in a few groups or there may have been less communication between the groups than is true after cancellation. Two, there is an established measure of betweenness centrality that shows the extent to which a single individual is on shortest paths for communication between individuals in the network. In the Trump collections before cancellation Trump was always the account with the largest measure of betweenness centrality. And he was often also the account with the largest betweenness centrality in the Biden collections though he was not mentioned nearly as frequently as was Biden. This is a good measure of the centrality of an individual in these networks. Post cancellation @RealDonaldTrump cannot be a participant in the networks and thus can no longer be the central figure he was before. And then the question is how does that change the center of the networks? Does another individual arise who becomes the central figure? Does the network, in this sense, become decentered?
We do not intend to ignore the text of the messages. What we want to examine is the character of Trump as that is communicated in the tweets before and after cancellation. Character is a central element in decisions in elections for candidates as well known as Trump. We have done research on this for the 2012 and 2016 elections. We believe this is a key to understanding who Donald Trump becomes over time.
We do not know what will happen during the next six months. Twitter may change their decision about communication by Donald Trump. Trump may attempt to communicate broadly on other social media services. But we can systematically look at what communication about Trump becomes on Twitter.