Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
“An election marks a moment of politics,” and it is not possible to understand the democratic purposes of popular voting, nor to diagnose its current ills without examining the temporal properties of these electoral moments. That was the core thesis of Dennis Thompson’s 2004 article “Election Time,” and it is time to revisit it.
Thompson argued that US elections are characterized by three temporal properties: periodicity, simultaneity, and finality. Recognizing these properties and their democratic value allows us to critique “anomalies” in electoral processes that violate these properties. But what happens when the anomalies aren’t anomalous anymore? One of the most notable anomalies that Thompson critiques is the violation of simultaneity presented by early and mail-in voting. In 2004, casting a vote prior to Election Day was indeed anomalous, but soon the opposite may be true. In the 2020 federal election, sixty four percent of votes were cast prior to Election Day. Though this was partially in response to concerns about the spread of COVID-19, it was also simply an acceleration in an existing trend toward so-called “convenience voting.” This recent dramatic shift away from the norm of simultaneous voting calls for renewed scrutiny from normative democratic theorists. This paper answers that call.
In this paper, I provide a new account of the significance of temporality in electoral systems, and of the value of special “moments” or occasions for popular voting, which serves as an alternative to Thompson’s original account. Thompson’s claims that temporal anomalies in the electoral process represent inherent threats to fairness, accountability, and independent judgment are not at the core of what we should worry about when we worry about Election Time. These threats are relatively minor compared to the ineradicable limitations of electoral representation. Instead, I extend and update an underdeveloped point within Thompson’s argument. The momentousness of occasions for popular voting, combined with other distinctive features of elections (namely mass participation, and aggregative equality), plays an important role in the formation of civic attitudes and habits and in the creation of an environment that is favorable to political innovation, organization, and mobilization.
Shifting attention to the effects of election moments on political attitudes and on the political environment changes our diagnosis of the most serious problems that arise with disturbances of Election time. This change in diagnosis also changes how we should approach finding treatments. Lamentable though it may be, it is unlikely, in the United States, at least, that we will return to a norm of simultaneous voting any time soon. We must, therefore, work to understand how to mitigate or compensate for the effects of the loss of simultaneity on citizen attitudes and the political culture. This paper offers some suggestions for what that might look like based on convenience voting research from the past two decades and outlines an agenda for future research.