Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Why Some Politicians Are forgiven and Others Are Punished

Fri, October 1, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Politicians’ moral behaviors affect how voters evaluate them and yet scholars have been puzzled by voters’ heterogeneous reactions to politicians’ immoral behavior. Why are some politicians (electorally) punished for a moral transgression, but others forgiven? Most political science research focuses on how immoral behavior by politicians affects voters’ voting behavior. The result is that scholars find politicians are often not punished electorally, surviving scandals to continue in office. Yet, this does not mean that voters do not care. Even in surviving electorally, politicians may pay a price in terms of popularity and effectiveness. In this paper, we move beyond electoral outcomes and examine voters’ intentions to hold politicians accountable through desires for retributive and restorative justice. Retributive justice is primarily concerned with unilateral punishment of transgressors, while restorative justice encourages bilateral efforts to restore the relationship between the victim and the transgressor. Here we examine how voters’ intention to punish or forgive politicians’ immoral behavior is dependent group membership (in -or outparty), perceived severity of the moral violation, whether -in or outgroup moral standards are violated, the degree of centrality of the partisan identity, and the voter’s own moral identity. We conduct 6 × 3 between‐subjects vignette experiments asking a random sample of 3000 U.S. to respond to politicians’ moral violations. We randomly vary the moral principle violated (Care, Fairness, Loyalty, Authority, Sanctity, and a social norms violation as control) and the partisanship of the actor (Republic/Democrat/Nonpartisan.) This study contributes to the field by broadening the examination of voters’ heterogeneous responses to political scandals and intergroup bias in moral punishment.

Authors