Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Not Eligible But Still Fitted?: Naturalization and the Asian Question, 1882-1906

Tue, September 28, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

According to the Naturalization Act of 1790 (1 Stat. 103), no alien but “a free white person” could apply for American citizenship through naturalization. Congress extended the right to naturalization to racial minorities in 1870, but not by striking out the racial prerequisite for naturalization altogether. Instead, it passed the law (16 Stat. 254) extending naturalization eligibility to another specified racial group: “aliens of African nativity and … persons of African descent.” Hence anyone who was neither “white” nor “black” remained excluded from acquiring citizenship by naturalization. Prior to the emergence of the Federal Bureau of Naturalization, however, the state courts often played a profound role unmoored from the close supervision of the federal government. Without openly calling for the revision of the nation’s naturalization restrictions, the state courts managed to use their discretion to open the possibilities of naturalization to some Asians for the benefit of the community or other interests. This paper explores how racial discrimination against Asians took shape through a variety of institutional efforts between 1882 and 1906, and how these years witnessed the dissonance between the federal naturalization laws and the realities on the ground. In addition to providing an analysis of relevant case law as well as institutional development, this study focuses on the lives of two Korean immigrants living in Pennsylvania and Washington D.C.—Philip Jaisohn and Pom Kwang Soh—and charts the strategies through which they strove to achieve American citizenship in an unfavorable legal and political context. It also highlights the evolution of multi-layered racial categories, the then expanding national government power over race relations and immigration—often in conflict with states’ enduring regulatory power—and the role of racial minorities and immigrants as transformative agents in naturalization politics.

Author