Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
This paper is part of a larger project arguing that it is time for us to break up, specifically, time to separate the current United States into two, three or more new nation states, and to achieve this process through a peaceful, negotiated, and mutually consensual breakup. The positive argument for such a negotiated divorce is rooted in a principle common to all theories of representative democracy—participants’ precommitment to elections—and an empirical judgment that such a precommitment is increasingly absent from a significant share of both the populace and the political elite of the United States. A process of mutually negotiated state-breaking—not a unilateral secession in the classical sense—would enable the new plural nation-states to enact the democratically necessary precommitment to electoral choice of representatives in their own new nation states.
Consider the principle of democratic precommitment first. The fundamental argument for this is that, in order to cooperate on shared schemes of action, even under conditions of severe disagreement over the best way to so cooperate—what Waldron rightly labels the two ‘conditions of politics’—there must be a sufficiently robust and widespread commitment amongst citizens and officials to employ established decision procedures, procedures for determining which cooperative schemes to adopt even while continuing to disagree. Such a procedural commitment is a requirement for working and peaceful cooperation at nation-state scale. All democratic theories of representative government—from minimalist to pluralist and on to deliberative theories, and despite whatever else they disagree upon—agree that one key procedural commitment is that officials are to be selected through free, fair, and regular elections. Said briefly, in order to cooperate democratically under the conditions of politics, we need large-scale procedural commitment to elections: the ‘democratic precommitment.’ Whatever value representative democracy might have and however deep and broad we might want democracy to be, it simply cannot be maintained absent a lowest common denominator: the precommitment to select political officials through free, fair, and regular elections. Further, this precommitment must be widely shared across officials, political organizations, and the general citizenry.
Putting this simple principle of democratic precommitment together with an honest assessment of conditions in the United States, I claim, entails that it is time for us to become Splitsville US, time to break us up. Although the history goes back further, this lack of precommitment was unmistakable in the run-up to the 2016 national presidential election, when one of the two major party candidates refused to commit orally to honor the outcome of a free and fair election. That candidate was supported by officials and other elites throughout one of only two major parties. After election, that candidate consolidated power over the political party, its base of supporting citizens, ancillary political organizations and allied centers of power. In the most recent election, the lack of democratic precommitment could not have been more evident. The losing official attempted an autogolpe, was widely and substantially supported in this by an overwhelming (but luckily not decisive) majority of his party’s elected officials, maintained or increased his popularity amongst the party’s citizenry, and instigated a violent insurrection against the legislature certifying his electoral loss. Given the incentive structures of current national politics in the United States—the particularities of our constitutional and electoral structures, party organizations, public spheres of mass and social media, social identity polarization, and so on—it seems reasonably foreseeable that this is now the new normal for United States politics: losing parties and candidates will use all means possible to undermine, ignore and overturn the results of elections. We—the United States as a political entity—no longer collectively endorse the democratic precommitment, and this is likely to get worse. However, splitting up into two or more new nation states could well enable each of the new entities to robustly precommit to the outcomes of democratic elections. It is time for us to exercise our ‘revolutionary right to dismember’ (Lincoln) our current dysfunctional union.
This paper concludes with brief indications of other parts of this larger project, considering: ancillary benefits of United States state-breaking including for constitutional reform, governability, social welfare, indigenous sovereignty, and the international order; moral and other costs including for migration, oppression, authoritarianism, monetary costs, property, and violence; current political and other incentives for and against such a course of action; and, suggestions for resolving problems of bounding the resulting demoi.