Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Share Your Story: Technology, Power, and Representation in Crowdsourced Advocacy

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

The emergence of story-centered advocacy campaigns and the growing popularity of techniques such as digital “story banking” – i.e. the “large-scale collection, digital archiving, and cataloguing of personal stories for […] incorporation in advocacy initiatives” (Trevisan et al., 2020) – offer previously marginalized voices new opportunities to influence political discourse and policy-making. However, it remains unclear whether this crowd-sourced approach to narrative building contributes to “democratizing” advocacy campaigns and broadens the range of people and issues they represent or, instead, exploits marginalized voices to support organizationally-directed agendas. To shed light on this issue, it is essential to better understand how the constantly changing political and technological landscape empowers or constrains storytellers from marginalized groups to express their voice.

In light of this, this paper examines the changing relationship between storytellers and advocacy organizations with a specific focus on the impact of technology, technological practices, organizational culture, and community engagement. In doing so, it focuses on questions of power and voice (including appropriation), illuminates story-development processes and control mechanisms, and assesses the “distance” between storytellers and stories published in digital advocacy campaigns. The overarching story production process is discussed with special attention to platform design, technical and narrative requirements for both story collection and dissemination, as well as the identity and role of any story editors and curators: are they storytelling professionals “parachuted” into communities, members, or allies of the communities themselves?

To address these questions, this paper examines a range of sources. Permissions and practices associated with collecting, storing, using, and sharing stories with relevant publics and other organizations are examined. Focusing on over 100 online story collection forms of U.S.-based story banking advocacy organizations, we show they almost invariably include broad permissions that are primarily informed by legal frameworks and legal teams within organizations. Interviews with advocacy organizations also demonstrate that ethical principles are important, as well as the need to maintain a good relationship with storytellers for strategic long-term reasons, and to avoid backlash.

However, this generates a precarious balance between the rights of individual storytellers and those of the organizations, which essentially rests on individuals within organizations doing their job in a certain way. This also exposes individual storytellers to potential backlash from online trolls and politically-motivated actors, which organizations are admittedly under-prepared and under-resourced to address effectively and impacts people who are often already in a vulnerable position. This has a potentially detrimental effect on the diversity and representativeness of crowd-sourced story-based advocacy too, because multiply marginalized people, whose voices are especially needed to be heard, are those at greatest risk in this political and technological context, and therefore may opt not to participate.

To illustrate these points, this paper reviews case studies and examples representative of different practices and approaches to online story collection, development, and production, from those that give storytellers both production skills and control over the final narrative (for example, the World Food Program’s Storytellers Program), to those where storytellers have very little control over the final product. The chapter concludes by discussing the implications of these approaches for public representations of minority groups and sensitive issues. In particular, it discusses how organizations, as they continue to invest in crowd-sourced storytelling, should consider the intersection of technology, strategic goals, and storyteller support in order to promote truly empowering innovation in advocacy.

Authors