Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Presidential Promise-Keeping and National Security

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper examines the extent to which presidents keep their campaign promises on issues related to national security. I analyze party platforms, campaign speeches, written statements, and debates from presidential elections for the years 1992-2008. I identify 1) narrow campaign pledges that specify a clear policy action, 2) broad pledges that promise action but do not specify the type of action, and 3) policy positions that do not entail a promise of action, but establish the candidate’s ideological position. Finally, the data codes whether/when pledges are fulfilled, not fulfilled, or partially fulfilled and whether/when the candidate’s policy position is upheld, violated, or partially violated. The results reveal an interesting paradox: although presidents fulfill or partially fulfill a majority of their campaign pledges on security, they mostly violate or partially violate their policy positions. The results also show that when presidents violate their policy positions, they have public support for their decision, although this support fades over time. The findings help resolve the contradiction between scholarly research, which shows that candidates keep their campaign promises, and the common view that candidates usually break them by showing that candidates rarely violate specific promises, but do change their policy positions.

Author